Zum Inhalt springen
Davidhorn
  • Lösungen

    Nach Branche

    • Polizei
    • Verteidigung
    • Einwanderung und Zoll
    • Vernehmungen von Kindern und Zeugen
    • Kommunalbehörden
    • Unternehmensuntersuchungen
    • Gesundheitswesen

    Nach Anwendungsfall

    • Vernehmung von schutzbedürftigen Zeugen
    • Vernehmungsräumen
    • Vernehmung vor Ort
  • Produkte

    Aufnahmegeräte

    • Aufzeichnungsapp
    • Portable Recorder
    • Mini Recorder
    • Fixed Recorder
    • Software Recorder
    • Verdeckte Aufnahmegeräte

    Interview-Management

    • Ark Vernehmungsmanagement

    Integrationen

    • Integrationen & Konfiguration
    Promotional graphic for a free webinar titled 'How to Use Davidhorn's Investigative Interview Solution,' hosted by Magnus Green. Features a blue speech bubble icon with the text 'Free webinar' and a blurred-out image of a person inside a blue circle.
  • Kunden
  • Ressourcen Hub

    Ressourcen Hub

    • Blog
    • Datenblätter
    • eBooks und Whitepapers
    • Ereignisse
    • Podcasts
    • Webinare
  • Partner

    Partner

    • Partnerübersicht
    • Partner werden
  • Unternehmen

    Unternehmen

    • Über
    • KarriereKarriere bei Davidhorn
    • Kontakt
    • Kunden
  • wpml-ls-flagde
    • wpml-ls-flagen
    • wpml-ls-flagfr
    • wpml-ls-flages
    • wpml-ls-flagit
    • wpml-ls-flagpl
Unterstützung
Demo Buchen
Davidhorn
Konto
  • Lösungen
    • Nach Branche
      • Polizei
      • Verteidigung
      • Einwanderung und Zoll
      • Barnahus
      • Kommunalbehörden
      • Unternehmensuntersuchungen
    • Nach Anwendungsfällen
      • Vernehmung von schutzbedürftigen Zeugen
      • Verdächtigenvernehmung
      • Vernehmung vor Ort
  • Produkte
    • Ark Interview Management
    • Mobile Recorder
    • Portable Recorder
    • Mini Recorder
    • Fixed Recorder
    • Software Recorder
    • Verdeckte Aufnahmegeräte
    • Admin- und API-Integrationen
  • Kunden
  • Ressourcen-Hub
    • Blog
    • Datenblatt
    • eBooks
    • Events
    • Podcasts
    • Webinare
  • Partner
    • Partnerübersicht
    • Partner werden
  • Unternehmen
    • Über
    • Nachricht
    • Kontakt
Unterstützen Sie
Demo buchen
  • Davidhorn
  • Davidhorn Police Vernehmung Summit 2025 – Es ist vollbracht

    Davidhorn Police Vernehmung Summit 2025 – Es ist vollbracht
    Davidhorn Polizei Vernehmung Summit Logo

    Was?

    Erstmalig
    Davidhorn Police Vernehmung Summit

    Für wen?

    Ermittler und IT-Fachleute der Polizei

    Wann?

    5 – 6 März 2025

    Wo?

    Best Western Plus
    Flughafenhotel Kopenhagen

    Präsentationen der Veranstaltung ansehen

    DerGipfel der polizeilichen Vernehmungen 2025 ist jetzt vorbei

    Herausragende Redner

    Davidhorn Polizei Vernehmung Gipfelredner
    Therese Maria Rytter – Juristische Direktorin, Dänisches Institut gegen Folter; Vizepräsidentin, Europäisches Komitee zur Verhütung von Folter
    Laurence Alison MBE Sprecher auf dem Davidhorn Police Vernehmung Summit
    Prof. Laurence Alison MBE – ORBIT-Schöpfer und leitender Trainer
    Emily Alison spricht auf dem Davidhorn Police Vernehmung Summit
    Emily Alison – ORBIT-Schöpferin und leitende Trainerin
    Davidhorn Polizei Vernehmung Gipfelredner
    Xander Radpey – Polizei Oslo, Innovation, Ermittlungen und Aufklärung
    Davidhorn Polizei Vernehmung Gipfelredner
    Dr. Ivar Fahsing – Experte für Menschenrechte und strafrechtliche Ermittlungen
    Børge Hansen – CEO Davidhorn

    Der erste Gipfel für polizeiliche Vernehmungen ist beendet

    Am 5. und 6. März 2025 fand der Davidhorn Gipfel für polizeiliche Vernehmungen in Kastrup bei Kopenhagen statt. Die Veranstaltung brachte Strafverfolgungsexperten, Forscher, Ermittler und IT-Spezialisten aus ganz Europa zusammen, um Innovationen bei der Vernehmung von Ermittlern und der Aufzeichnung polizeilicher Vernehmungen zu erkunden.

    Tag 1 bietet Hauptvorträge von Polizeiführern und Befragungsexperten, die sich mit den neuesten Trends, Herausforderungen und Lösungen für polizeiliche Befragungen befassen werden.

    Tag 2 bestand aus einem eintägigen Einführungsworkshop in die ORBIT-Methode. Der Workshop wurde von den Forschern geleitet, die hinter dieser wissenschaftlichen und bahnbrechenden Methode zur Gewinnung hochwertiger Erkenntnisse aus Interviews stehen.

    Wir sind stolz darauf, einige der prominentesten Namen im Bereich investigativer Interviews in der Sendung zu haben, darunter Therese Maria Rytter über die Bedeutung von Investigativinterviews, Emily und Laurence Alison über den Aufbau von Beziehungen, Dr. Ivar Fahsing über neue globale Standards und Xander Radpey über KI-Implementierungen zur Verbesserung der Produktivität bei der norwegischen Polizei. Weitere Redner werden noch bekannt gegeben.

    Abgerundet wird Tag 1 mit einer spannenden Live-Aufnahme unseres beliebten Podcasts “Beyond a Reasonable Doubt“ und einer Networking-Session.

    Aufgrund des Erfolgs der Veranstaltung werden wir in Kürze den nächsten Davidhorn Police Vernehmung Summit ankündigen. Bleiben Sie auf dem Laufenden, indem Sie sich für unseren Newsletter anmelden.

    Davidhorn Police Vernehmung Summit ist Ihre Gelegenheit:

    • Verbinden Sie sich mit Gleichgesinnten aus ganz Europa
    • Lernen Sie von führenden Experten für polizeiliche Ermittlungsgespräche
    • Gewinnen Sie praktische Einblicke in Implementierungsstrategien
    • Entdecken Sie die neuesten technologischen Innovationen im Bereich der Vernehmungsaufzeichnung bei der Polizei


    Perfekt für Entscheidungsträger in der Strafverfolgung, Ermittler und IT-Experten, die in Polizeiorganisationen in ganz Europa arbeiten.

    Programm: Mittwoch 05 März

    Klicken Sie, um den Zeitplan zu sehen
    08:00 – 09:00Registrierung und Kaffee
    09:00 – 09:30Eröffnungs-Keynote.
    Børge Hansen,
    CEO, Davidhorn
    09:30 – 10:15Ermittlungsbefragungen als Mittel zur Verhinderung von Folter und anderer unmenschlicher Behandlung.
    Therese Maria Rytter,
    Juristische Direktorin von DIGNITY; Vizepräsidentin des Europäischen Komitees zur Verhütung von Folter
    10:15 – 10:30Kaffeepause
    10:30 – 11:15Neue globale Standards für Ermittlungsbefragungen.
    Dr. Ivar Fahsing, Experte für Menschenrechte und strafrechtliche Ermittlungen an der Universität Oslo, Juristische Fakultät, Zentrum für Menschenrechte, Internationale Abteilung
    11:15 – 12:00Innovationen bei der Polizei mit KI: Ein Fall aus Norwegen.
    Xander Radpey, Superintendent, Polizei Oslo
    12:00 – 13:00Mittagessen
    13:00 – 14:00Demo von Davidhorns Lösung für investigative Vernehmungen und ein Blick in die Zukunft.
    Magnus Green, CTO, Davidhorn
    14:00 – 14:15Produkt Q&A
    14:15 – 14:30 Kaffeepause
    14:30 – 15:15Präsentation: Einrichten von Interview-Suiten für die Aufnahme von Beweismaterial und was dabei zu beachten ist.
    Jeff Horn, General Manager UK, Davidhorn
    15:15 – 16:30Titel: InnovationTitel: Ermittlungen
    Workshop: Gestalten Sie die Zukunft
    Produkt-Workshop zur Gestaltung der Zukunft des Interviewraum-Recorders
    Grundsatzrede: Rapport aufbauen
    Dr. Laurence Alison, Prof. für Psychologie, Universität Liverpool
    16:30-17:00Pause
    17:00 – 18:00Podcast“Beyond a Reasonable Doubt“, live beim Police Vernehmung Summit:
    Prof. Laurence Alison und Dr. Ivar Fahsing
    18:00 – 21:00Soziale Netzwerke, Essen und Getränke

    Programm: Donnerstag 06 März

    Klicken Sie hier, um den Zeitplan zu überprüfen
    08:00 – 08:30Kaffee
    08:30 – 12:00ORBIT Workshop pt.1
    12:00 – 13:00Mittagessen
    13:00 – 17:00ORBIT Workshop pt.2


    ORBIT Workshop Beschreibung

    In diesem Seminar werden die Probleme diskutiert, die mit der Anwendung von Zwangsverhörmethoden verbunden sind, sowie die Vorteile der Anwendung humanistischer, beziehungsbasierter Ansätze.
    Zunächst wird die historische Anwendung harter Verhörmethoden in Nordamerika und Großbritannien sowie die Verlagerung von Verhören zu Ermittlungsgesprächen und die Einführung von zwangsfreien Ansätzen in Großbritannien dargestellt.

    Anschließend erhalten Sie einen Überblick über ORBIT – dem ersten empirisch fundierten und umfassenden Modell für Ermittlungsgespräche/Verhöre. ORBIT geht auf die Arbeit von Prof. Laurence Alison und Emily Alison zurück, die mit ihrem Team den weltweit größten Korpus realer Vernehmungen (mehr als 2.000 Stunden) analysiert haben, die von der britischen Polizei und dem Militär durchgeführt wurden.
    Seine primäre Forschungsgrundlage sind Vernehmungen, die von Polizei und Militär mit Terrorverdächtigen durchgeführt wurden. Es wurde auch bei polizeilichen Befragungen von Kindern und Opfern von Sexualdelikten validiert. ORBIT vereint mehr als 70 Jahre Forschung zu humanistischen therapeutischen Ansätzen und zwischenmenschlichen Beziehungen und bietet ein theoretisch fundiertes Modell der beziehungsbasierten Kommunikation für Ermittlungs- und Geheimdienstbefragungen.

    Als international anerkanntes Modell wurde ORBIT in Großbritannien, den USA und in anderen Ländern eingesetzt, um lebenswichtige Informationen zu sichern. Es wurde für eine Reihe von Organisationen ausgebildet, darunter britische, US-amerikanische und niederländische Strafverfolgungsbehörden und Militärteams, die britische Einheit für Kriegsverbrechen, die britische Border Force Intelligence, die norwegische Polizei zur Terrorismusbekämpfung und internationale humanitäre Organisationen.

    Dezember 5, 2025
  • Redfish Australia

    Redfish Australia

    Redfish: Ein vertrauenswürdiger Partner in Australien

    Wir sind stolz darauf, unsere Partnerschaft mit Redfish Technologies Pty Ltd hervorzuheben, einem innovativen australischen Unternehmen, das sich auf digitale Aufzeichnung und hochwertige AV-Integration und -Implementierung spezialisiert hat. Gemeinsam liefern wir fortschrittliche Aufzeichnungslösungen an Strafverfolgungsbehörden in ganz Australien. In diesem Blogbeitrag beleuchten wir die bemerkenswerte Arbeit von Redfish Technologies und wie unsere Zusammenarbeit die Art und Weise verändert, wie Beweise gesammelt und verwaltet werden.

    Redfish: A Trusted Partner in Australia

    Zusammenfassung

    • Expertise und Innovation: Redfish Technologies zeichnet sich durch die Bereitstellung hochwertiger digitaler Aufzeichnungs- und Präsentationslösungen für die Strafverfolgung aus und ist auf komplexe Umgebungen wie Child Abuse Investigation Teams (CAIT) spezialisiert. Ihr kundenorientierter Ansatz gewährleistet maßgeschneiderte, effektive Lösungen unter Einsatz modernster audio-visueller Technologien.
    • Installations-Best Practices: Mit umfangreicher Erfahrung im Design und in der Installation von Befragungsräumen hat Redfish Technologies Best Practices für die Erfassung hochwertiger Beweise entwickelt. Ihre Installationen zielen darauf ab, das Trauma für gefährdete und eingeschüchterte Zeugen zu reduzieren und die Erzielung bestmöglicher Beweise (ABE) zu gewährleisten.
    • Erfolge der Zusammenarbeit: In Partnerschaft mit Davidhorn hat Redfish Technologies die australische Strafverfolgung maßgeblich beeinflusst, insbesondere durch die Installation von 120 Befragungsrekordern. Ihr umfassendes Angebot umfasst feste Installationen, tragbare Rekorder, mobile Apps und zentralisierte Serverlösungen, die das Management und die Sammlung von Beweisen verbessern.
    Mehr erfahren

    Expertise in komplexen Umgebungen

    Redfish Technologies war entscheidend bei der Bereitstellung von Installationen für Ermittlungsbefragungen in der gesamten Strafverfolgungsbranche. Mit einer erfolgreichen Projektdurchführung, die eine breite Palette von Kundenanforderungen erfüllt, haben sie zusammen mit Davidhorn-Anwendungen und neuen, hochmodernen audio-visuellen Technologien hochwertige digitale Aufzeichnungs- und Präsentationslösungen geschaffen. Redfish ist stolz darauf, die Anforderungen der Kunden klar zu verstehen und effektive Lösungen zu liefern, die die gewünschten Ziele der Kunden erreichen. Ihre langjährige Erfahrung in der Bereitstellung von Befragungs- und Verdächtigungsräumen, insbesondere für CAIT (Child Abuse Investigation Teams), war von unschätzbarem Wert.

    Innovative Lösungen

    Sie sind bekannt für ihre Kundenorientierung und Innovationskraft, ihre Expertise erstreckt sich auf alle aktuellen, bewährten AV- und Aufzeichnungstechnologien. Dies stellt sicher, dass Redfish Technologies für jede spezifische Anforderung eines Kunden – sei es in Gerichtssälen, bei Tribunalen oder bei Strafverfolgungsbehörden – eine maßgeschneiderte Lösung bietet.

    Installations-Best Practices

    Redfish Technologies hat durch ihre enge Zusammenarbeit mit Kunden und ihre Design-/Installationsarbeit umfangreiche Erfahrungen mit den spezifischen Anforderungen einer Vielzahl unterschiedlicher Befragungssituationen gesammelt. Aus unserer Erfahrung haben Partner, die so eng mit Kunden zusammenarbeiten wie Redfish Technologies, Best Practices für die Erfassung hochwertiger Beweise entwickelt. Dies ist besonders wichtig bei der Installation von Befragungsräumen für gefährdete und eingeschüchterte Zeugen, da dies dazu beitragen kann, das Trauma zu reduzieren, das oft erneut erlebt wird, wenn ein Zeuge Ermittlungen und Gerichtsverhandlungen durchläuft. Die Erzielung bestmöglicher Beweise (ABE) bei der Aufzeichnung von Ermittlungsinterviews ist daher entscheidend und kann nur konsequent erreicht werden, wenn Befragungsräume mit diesem Ziel im Hinterkopf sorgfältig geplant und installiert werden.


    Erfolge der Zusammenarbeit

    Partnerschaft mit der Strafverfolgung

    Unsere gemeinsamen Unternehmungen haben in der australischen Strafverfolgung bemerkenswerte Auswirkungen erzielt. Ein solches Beispiel ist die Zusammenarbeit mit einer australischen Polizeibehörde, bei der Redfish Technologies erfolgreich 120 Befragungsrekorder zusammen mit zugehörigen audio-visuellen Unterstützungstechnologien und unserer Lösung für das digitale Beweismittelmanagement installiert hat.

    Umfassendes Angebot

    Diese Projekte boten einen umfassenden Ansatz, der feste Installationen für Verdächtigen- und ABE-Räume mit besonderem Fokus auf die spezifischen Anforderungen von CAIT-Teams umfasste. Das Angebot umfasste auch tragbare Rekorder, mobile Apps und eine zentralisierte Serverlösung, um alle gesammelten Beweise nahtlos zu verwalten.

    Fazit

    Unsere Partnerschaft mit Redfish Technologies ist ein Zeugnis für die großartige Arbeit, die sie im technischen und AV-Bereich leisten. Es ist uns eine Ehre, dass sie sich entschieden haben, unsere hochmodernen Aufzeichnungslösungen an australische Strafverfolgungsbehörden zu liefern. Wir sind zuversichtlich, dass wir gemeinsam weiterhin Fortschritte in der Branche machen werden, um die höchste Qualität bei der Beweissammlung und -verwaltung für die kommenden Jahre sicherzustellen.

    Wir freuen uns darauf, unsere Zusammenarbeit weiter zu stärken und erstklassige Lösungen für die Erfassung und Verwaltung wichtiger Beweise in verschiedenen Umgebungen bereitzustellen. Vielen Dank, Redfish Technologies, dass Sie mehr als nur ein Lieferant sind – ein wahrer Partner für Gerechtigkeit.

    Verwandte Produkte

    • Fixed Vernehmungsrekorder

      Vernehmungsrekorder von Davidhorn: Vielseitiger HD-Recorder für Verdächtige, Zeugenbefragungen und ABE-Aufnahmen….

    • Beweiserfassung: Aufzeichnungsapp

      Beweiserfassung mit Davidhorn: Erfassen Sie Ereignisse, führen Sie Tatortmanagement durch und zeichnen Sie…

    • Software zur Vernehmungsverwaltung: Ark

      Empfangen, überwachen und archivieren Sie Beweismittel während der gesamten Lebensdauer mit einer umfassenden…

    Juni 18, 2024
  • Wie Sie Davidhorns Lösung zur Aufzeichnung von Ermittlungsgesprächen verwenden.

    Wie Sie Davidhorns Lösung zur Aufzeichnung von Ermittlungsgesprächen verwenden.

    Wie Sie Davidhorns Lösung für investigative Interviews verwenden. Webinar mit Davidhorn CTO Magnus Green.

    (Live-aufgezeichnetes Webinar vom Davidhorn Police Interview Summit 2025)

    Füllen Sie das Formular aus, um das Webinar anzusehen.Bitte füllen Sie alle erforderlichen Felder (*) aus, bevor Sie Ihre Anfrage absenden.

    Unser letztes Webinar, das während des Davidhorn Police Interview Summit 2025 aufgezeichnet wurde, wurde von Magnus Green, Chief Technology Officer bei Davidhorn, moderiert.

    Magnus bot eine exklusive praktische Demonstration unserer umfassenden Lösung für investigative Befragungen, bei der über 40 Jahre Forschung und Entwicklung in Aktion gezeigt wurden.

    In diesem praktischen Durchgang erkundet Magnus:

    • Komplettes Interview-Workflow-Management – Von der anfänglichen Planung bis zur Analyse nach dem Interview, wobei gezeigt wird, wie Technologie den gesamten Ermittlungsprozess unterstützt
    • Demonstration von Echtzeit-Interviews – Live-Aufnahme von Interviews, die eine nahtlose Integration zwischen Planung, Durchführung und Überwachung von Interviews zeigt
    • Integrität digitaler Beweise – Wie Digital Fingerprint SHA-256 und Verschlüsselung Beweise vor Manipulationen schützen und gleichzeitig die Zulässigkeit vor Gericht wahren
    • Fortgeschrittene Transkription und KI-Unterstützung – Automatisierte Sprache-zu-Text-Transkription mit menschlicher Aufsicht, um Genauigkeit und Zuverlässigkeit zu gewährleisten
    • Sichere Freigabefunktionen – Systeme mit kontrolliertem Zugriff für die Freigabe von Beweismitteln an Rechtsvertreter unter Beibehaltung von Prüfpfaden und Sicherheit
    • Flexible Bereitstellungsoptionen – Browser-basierte Lösungen, die geräteübergreifend funktionieren und gleichzeitig die Anforderungen an die Datensouveränität respektieren

    Die Demonstration von Magnus zeigte, wie moderne Vernehmungsmanagement-Technologie die Arbeitsabläufe bei Ermittlungen rationalisiert und gleichzeitig die höchsten Standards für die Integrität von Beweismitteln einhält. Diese Lösung wurde mit Hilfe von Praktikern entwickelt, um Probleme aus der Praxis zu lösen. Sie steigert die Effizienz, ohne die Qualität oder Zulässigkeit von Beweisen zu beeinträchtigen.

    Entdecken Sie, wie diese bewährte Technologie die Befragung von Ermittlern von der Planung bis zur Präsentation im Gerichtssaal verändert und die Justiz durch Innovation unterstützt.

    „*“ zeigt erforderliche Felder an

    Dieses Feld dient zur Validierung und sollte nicht verändert werden.
    Einverständnis

    Juni 23, 2025
  • Isländische Polizei

    Isländische Polizei

    Die Auswirkungen der Davidhorn-Systeme auf die isländische Polizeiarbeit

    Zwischen 2000 und 2003 orchestrierte die IT-Abteilung der zentralen Polizeibehörde in Island einen bahnbrechenden Übergang durch die Einführung und Implementierung eines Systems namens LOKE. Im Jahr 2005 war LOKE voll funktionsfähig, vereinte sieben unterschiedliche Systeme in einem und führte eine Vielzahl dringend benötigter neuer Funktionen ein.

    Zusammenfassung

    • Implementierung und Integration: Die zentrale Polizeibehörde in Island implementierte das LOKE-System und vereinte bis 2005 sieben unterschiedliche Systeme in einem. Im Jahr 2013 integrierten sie die Vernehmungsaufzeichnungenslösung von Davidhorn in LOKE, wodurch die Aufzeichnung und Weitergabe von Vernehmungen optimiert wurde.
    • Auswirkungen und Anerkennung: Dieser technologische Fortschritt machte Island zu einem Vorbild für andere Länder und erregte weltweite Aufmerksamkeit, auch von Microsoft. Árni E. Albertsson präsentierte ihre innovative Arbeit auf dem Police Strategy Forum in Oxfordshire,
    • Effizienz und Sicherheit: Die Einführung der Lösung von Davidhorn verbesserte die Effizienz, Sicherheit und Benutzerfreundlichkeit bei der Handhabung von Vernehmungsaufzeichnungen, indem von CDs auf ein zentrales digitales System mit erweitertem Zugriffskontrollsystem und obligatorischer Videoaufzeichnung bei schweren Fällen umgestellt wurde.
    Mehr erfahren

    Im Jahr 2013 erwarb und implementierte die Polizei eine Vernehmungsaufzeichnungslösung von Davidhorn, die in die LOKE-Benutzeroberfläche integriert wurde. Dank dieses zukunftsorientierten Ansatzes konnte die isländische Strafverfolgung ihre Abläufe bei der Aufzeichnung und Weitergabe von Vernehmungen optimieren und sich damit zu einem Vorbild für andere Länder entwickeln.

    Anerkennung für ihre innovativen Leistungen: Einer der Teammitglieder, Árni E. Albertsson, wurde eingeladen, auf dem Police Strategy Forum 2017 in Oxfordshire die Arbeit der isländischen Polizei mit Davidhorn vorzustellen. Das Engagement des Teams für den technologischen Fortschritt im Bereich der Strafverfolgung hat nachhaltige Auswirkungen gehabt und den Weg für effizientere und effektivere Polizeiarbeit geebnet.

    Suche nach sichereren und effektiveren Arbeitsweisen

    Vor der Einführung der Davidhorn-Lösung stieß die isländische Polizei auf erhebliche Schwierigkeiten bei der Verwaltung von Vernehmungsaufzeichnungen. Das Teilen dieser Vernehmungen zwischen Abteilungen oder Bezirken bedeutete, auf CDs angewiesen zu sein, was nicht nur hohe Kosten verursachte, sondern auch anfällig für Fehler, Beschädigungen und Verluste war. Die Polizeibezirke, bestrebt, Kosten zu sparen und Sicherheit sowie Effizienz zu verbessern, suchten nach einer Lösung, die es ihnen ermöglicht, Aufzeichnungen auf sicherere und effektivere Weise zu teilen, mit einfachem Zugang und Verteilung für diejenigen, die sie benötigten.

    Die Lösung wurde erstmals 2015 eingeführt, und bis 2018-2019 hatte die isländische Polizei erhebliche Fortschritte bei der Zusammenführung ihrer verschiedenen Systeme erzielt. Die Entwicklung der IT-Infrastruktur der isländischen Polizei verlief von 27 getrennten Polizeibezirken, die als unabhängige Inseln operierten, hin zu einem zentralisierten System.

    Vereinfachter Ansatz

    Dieser vereinfachte Ansatz zur Handhabung und zum Teilen von Vernehmungen bot erweiterte Zugangskontroll- und Protokollierungsfunktionen, die es den Administratoren erleichterten, zu überwachen, wer Zugriff auf bestimmte Aufzeichnungen hatte. Davidhorn unterstützte das Team während des gesamten Implementierungsprozesses mit Schulungen. 2016 hielt Davidhorn Vorträge in Island und schulte 30 Personen. Diese pädagogische Unterstützung stellte sicher, dass die isländische Polizei die Technologie optimal nutzen konnte.

    Vernehmungsaufzeichnungstechnologie hat sich zu einem unverzichtbaren Werkzeug für die isländische Polizei entwickelt und ist nun eine vorgeschriebene Praxis der Staatsanwaltschaft für schwere Fälle. Laut diesen Vorschriften müssen alle Zeugen- und Verdächtigenvernehmungen in bedeutenden Fällen videoaufgezeichnet werden, was die kritische Rolle der Technologie in der modernen Strafverfolgung unterstreicht.

    Weltweite Aufmerksamkeit

    Der innovative Ansatz der isländischen Polizei erregte die Aufmerksamkeit anderer Länder und sogar führender Technologieunternehmen wie Microsoft. Das in Seattle ansässige Unternehmen besuchte Island, um mehr über deren Lösungen und die Nutzung von Microsoft-Produkten zu erfahren. Sie waren auch an der Entwicklung einer mobilen App für isländische Polizeifahrzeuge beteiligt.

    Mit der Lösung von Davidhorn hat die isländische Polizei die Art und Weise, wie sie Vernehmungen aufzeichnet, erheblich verbessert, was ihre Abläufe effizienter, sicherer und benutzerfreundlicher macht.

    Verfasst von: Marta Hopfer-Gilles

    (Chat GPT wurde bei der Erstellung dieses Blogs verwendet)

    Verwandte Produkte

    • Software zur Vernehmungsverwaltung: Ark

      Empfangen, überwachen und archivieren Sie Beweismittel während der gesamten Lebensdauer mit einer umfassenden…

    • Beweiserfassung: Aufzeichnungsapp

      Beweiserfassung mit Davidhorn: Erfassen Sie Ereignisse, führen Sie Tatortmanagement durch und zeichnen Sie…

    • Tragbarer Vernehmungs-Recorder

      Leichter Vernehmungsrekorder für jede Umgebung, der den strengsten Gesetzen entspricht.

    Juni 18, 2024
  • Wie Sie einen Aufnahmeraum für ein polizeiliche Vernehmungen einrichten.

    Wie Sie einen Aufnahmeraum für ein polizeiliche Vernehmungen einrichten.
    Webinar on police interview recording suites with Jeff Horn

    Wie man einen Aufnahmeraum für polizeiliche Vernehmungen einrichtet. Webinar mit Jeff Horn.

    (Live-aufgezeichnetes Webinar vom Davidhorn Police Interview Summit 2025)

    Füllen Sie das Formular aus, um das Webinar anzusehen. Bitte füllen Sie alle erforderlichen Felder (*) aus, bevor Sie Ihre Anfrage absenden.


    Unser jüngstes Webinar, das während des Davidhorn Police Interview Summit 2025 aufgezeichnet wurde, wurde von Jeff Horn, dem Geschäftsführer von Davidhorn UK, moderiert. Jeff verfügt über jahrzehntelange Erfahrung darin, sicherzustellen, dass wichtige Ermittlungsergebnisse vor Gericht als zulässige Beweise gelten.
    In dieser umfassenden technischen Präsentation ging Jeff auf folgende Punkte ein:

    • Wissenschaftliche Grundlagen der polizeilichen Vernehmungsprotokolle – Ausgehend von den ursprünglichen britischen Studien, die die PACE-Gesetzgebung begründeten, und den Lehren aus historischen Fällen wie den Guildford Four
    • Audio als primäres Beweismittel – Verstehen, warum klarer, hörbarer Ton Vorrang vor Video hat, und die technischen Anforderungen für die Zulässigkeit vor Gericht
    • Überlegungen zur Raumgestaltung und Umgebung – Praktische Hinweise zur akustischen Behandlung, zur Kamerapositionierung und zur Schaffung optimaler Aufnahmeumgebungen sowohl für Verdächtigenbefragungen als auch für gefährdete Zeugenaussagen
    • Technologiestandards für fälschungssichere polizeiliche Vernehmungsprotokolle – Die entscheidende Rolle des digitalen Fingerabdrucks (SHA-256), der AES-256-Verschlüsselung und der Erhaltung der Integrität der Beweiskette
    • Spezielle Überlegungen für schutzbedürftige Zeugen – Technische Anpassungen für Kinderbefragungen und traumatisierende Aufzeichnungsmethoden

    „*“ zeigt erforderliche Felder an

    Dieses Feld dient zur Validierung und sollte nicht verändert werden.
    Einverständnis

    Jeffs Präsentation zeigte auf, wie sich die ordnungsgemäße technische Implementierung von Aufnahmesystemen direkt auf die Zulässigkeit und Qualität von Beweisen auswirkt. So wird sichergestellt, dass die wichtige Arbeit der Ermittler und der Mut der Zeugen im Gerichtssaal effektiv umgesetzt werden.
    Entdecken Sie, wie diese evidenzbasierten technischen Standards und bewährten Methoden die Justiz unterstützen und gleichzeitig die Integrität sowohl des Ermittlungsprozesses als auch derjenigen, die an ihm beteiligt sind, schützen.

    Juni 10, 2025
  • Polizei Schleswig-Holstein

    Polizei Schleswig-Holstein

    Polizei Schleswig-Holstein:
    Neudefinition von Opferbefragungen

    Mit spürbarer Hingabe an die Opfer hat sich das Team in Schleswig-Holstein auf eine Mission begeben.

    Zusammenfassung

    • Lesen Sie, wie die Transformation in der Opferbetreuung bei Sexualdelikten durch die Polizei Schleswig-Holstein umgesetzt wurde durch:
    • Innovative Unterstützung bei Opferbefragungen: Um die Betreuung zu verbessern, konzentrierte sich das Team, das mit Opfern sexueller Gewalt arbeitet, auf opferzentrierte Arbeitsabläufe. Es wurden audio-visuelle Aufzeichnungen von Befragungen implementiert, um Traumata zu minimieren, und spezielle Schulungen für die Beamten, die Sexualdelikte bearbeiten, entwickelt.
    • Technologische und rechtliche Transformation: Ein wesentlicher Bestandteil der Transformation war die Einführung gerichtsfester Befragungsinstrumente, die Anpassung an gesetzliche Änderungen wie §58a StPO und die Zukunftsvision eines zentralisierten Datenmanagements, um effizientere und gerechtere gerichtliche Verfahren zu gewährleisten.
    • Führendes Beispiel für Deutschland: Die Kombination aus engagierten Beamten, innovativer Technologie und gesetzlicher Konformität in Schleswig-Holstein setzt Maßstäbe im Opferschutz und hat das Potenzial, andere Regionen bei der Unterstützung von Opfern sexueller Straftaten zu beeinflussen.

    Ihr Hauptziel?

    Sicherzustellen, dass der gesamte Prozess, von der ersten Beteiligung der Polizei bis zur endgültigen Entscheidung des Richters, opferzentriert bleibt. Sie strebten an, die Beweiserhebung zu verbessern, den Prozess zu straffen und technologische Herausforderungen zu meistern.

    Was in Schleswig-Holstein erreicht wurde, war nichts weniger als revolutionär. Alles begann vor über 25 Jahren mit dem audio-dokumentierten Vernehmung. Heute werden solche Vernehmungen überall audio-visuell aufgezeichnet. Sie entwickelten einen Ansatz, der auf internationalen Best Practices basiert und sowohl den Opferschutz als auch die Beweiserhebung durch Befragungsmethoden verbesserte. Dieser Ansatz hat sich bewährt und kann als Beispiel für andere Polizeikräfte in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland dienen, um die Betreuung von Opfern während des Befragungsprozesses zu verbessern.


    “Der erste Schritt zu einem guten Vernehmung ist es, es aufzuzeichnen. Wir suchten nach einem Unternehmen, das uns dabei helfen konnte. Ein Kontakt empfahl uns 2012 Davidhorn (ehemals Indico Systems) und es stellte sich als perfekte Lösung für uns heraus. Wir schafften es, unsere Ermittlungsoperationen auf ein neues Level zu bringen. Wir arbeiten seitdem mit ihnen zusammen.”
    Uwe Keller ehemaliger Polizist Schleswig-Holstein

    Zentral für diesen neuen Ansatz war ein grundlegender Wandel in den Befragungstechniken. Die Aufzeichnung von Vernehmungen und die Anwendung von Ermittlungsmethoden haben sich als bahnbrechend erwiesen, da sie die Anzahl der Wiederholungen, bei denen Opfer ihre Traumata erneut durchleben müssen, reduziert haben.

    Ihre Suche nach technologischen Lösungen führte die Polizei von Schleswig-Holstein 2010 zu Davidhorn. Die Herausforderung? Einen technischen Weg zu finden, um gerichtsfeste Vernehmungen zu dokumentieren und so Mehrfachbefragungen durch die Polizei zu verhindern.

    Diese Transformation wurde nicht durch eine Gesetzesänderung oder eine offizielle Direktive ausgelöst. Stattdessen war sie das Ergebnis von Einzelpersonen innerhalb der Polizei, die von Leidenschaft, Entschlossenheit und dem Wunsch angetrieben wurden, die Perspektive der Opfer in den Vordergrund zu stellen. Inspiriert von der dänischen Polizei und deren Praktiken wollten sie die gleichen Standards nach Schleswig-Holstein bringen, insbesondere im Umgang mit Sexualverbrechen. Das Ziel? Die Arbeitsabläufe so anzupassen, dass den Ermittlungen der effektivste Start gegeben wird. Ein gutes ErstVernehmung ist der Schlüssel zu den folgenden Ermittlungen und Maßnahmen.

    Die Zusammenarbeit mit Davidhorn begann mit nur drei Testaufnahmesets. Diese Zahl hat sich im Laufe der Jahre erhöht und steht jetzt allen Sexualstraftatenteams in den 26 Kriminalpolizeidienststellen in Schleswig-Holstein zur Verfügung.

    Eine Gesetzesänderung im Jahr 2019, die die Befragungsprotokolle für verdächtige Jugendliche und Verdächtige in Mordfällen betraf, führte zur Erweiterung des Systems und zur Anschaffung weiterer Befragungskits. Heute verfügt Schleswig-Holstein über rund 60 dieser Instrumente. Für das Team, das hauptsächlich mit Sexualverbrechen arbeitet, haben sich tragbare Lösungen als besonders wertvoll erwiesen.

    Allerdings stellt sich die Polizei Schleswig-Holstein eine Zukunft mit einer zentralisierten Serverlösung vor, die die Notwendigkeit beseitigen könnte, Vernehmung-CDs im ganzen Land zu versenden – ein Prozess, der sowohl zeitaufwendig als auch fehleranfällig ist. Diese technischen Lösungen könnten in Zukunft Zeit und personelle Ressourcen sparen, indem sie eine automatische Transkriptionsfunktion „Speech to Text“ und KI-unterstützte Zusammenfassungen von Vernehmungen bieten.

    Gestaltung des neuen Paradigmas: Opferzentrierte Arbeitsabläufe

    Der neue Ansatz basiert auf einem entscheidenden ersten Schritt: der Durchführung eines gut dokumentierten Vernehmungen. Der Zweck? Ein Video-Vernehmung für alle Beteiligten verfügbar zu machen, um das Opfer vor einer erneuten Befragung vor Gericht zu bewahren, sodass es das Trauma nicht noch einmal durchleben muss. Eine Praxis, die seit 2019 in Deutschland gesetzlich vorgeschrieben ist.

    Die Praxis hat gezeigt, dass eine solches Vernehmung, die eine Hauptverhandlung vermeidet, am Ende der polizeilichen Maßnahmen sinnvoll ist, wenn alle Fakten ermittelt und festgestellt wurden. Aufgezeichnete polizeiliche Vernehmungen werden daher weiterhin durchgeführt.

    In dieser Hinsicht sticht Schleswig-Holstein hervor. Mit rund 1.200 jährlich durchgeführten Vernehmungen ist es im Vergleich zu einigen anderen Regionen führend.

    Neben der Änderung ihrer Befragungspraxis hat das Team in Schleswig-Holstein auch ein Handbuch mit Best Practices für Vernehmungen mit Opfern sexueller Verbrechen zusammengestellt. Diese Ressource dient als wertvolles Werkzeug für alle Kolleginnen und Kollegen in der Region, die mit diesen Fällen arbeiten.

    Dieses Handbuch ist zu einer Art „internem Gesetz“ innerhalb der Polizei geworden, und sein Einfluss erstreckt sich über Schleswig-Holstein hinaus. In der Vergangenheit wurde es unter anderem mit der Polizei in Slowenien, Hamburg, Berlin/Brandenburg und Niedersachsen geteilt.

    Die Task Force, die diese Best Practices für den Umgang mit Opfern sexueller Straftaten vorantreibt, besteht aus nur sieben Personen: einem Beamten der Polizeiakademie, zwei Staatsanwältinnen, drei Ermittlerinnen und einem Pressesprecher, der zuvor mit Sexualverbrechen gearbeitet hat. Sie sind die „Wächter“ dieser Standards in ganz Schleswig-Holstein.

    Ein bewusster und sensibler Umgang mit den Opfern steht im Mittelpunkt ihrer Mission und betont die Bedeutung der frühestmöglichen Aufzeichnung von Vernehmungen im Prozess. Diese prompte Maßnahme, wenn jemand zur Polizei kommt, um ein Sexualverbrechen zu melden, minimiert die Notwendigkeit, dass das Opfer sein Trauma durch erneutes Erzählen seiner Erlebnisse wiederholt durchleben muss.

    Die Transformation war das Ergebnis von Einzelpersonen innerhalb der Polizei, die von Leidenschaft, Entschlossenheit und dem Wunsch angetrieben wurden, die Perspektive der Opfer in den Vordergrund zu stellen.

    Gestaltung des neuen Paradigmas: Opfer-pionierende Praktiken: Schleswig-Holsteins progressiver Ansatz

    Schleswig-Holstein hat wirklich den Weg zu diesem neuen Mindset geebnet. Der entscheidende Faktor war die Planung einer koordinierten Anstrengung mit allen Prozessbeteiligten, um aufgezeichnete Vernehmungen in die Prozesse einzuführen. Ohne deren Zustimmung hätte das Vorhaben keine Chance gehabt. Es war ein gemeinsamer Weg mit Anwälten, Staatsanwälten und Richtern, um ein Umfeld zu schaffen, in dem auch sie die Vorteile dieses mitfühlenderen Ansatzes erkannten.

    Insbesondere im Bereich der Sexualdelikte beschäftigt die Region speziell geschulte Beamte. Von den 26 Dienststellen in Schleswig-Holstein haben rund 85 Beamte eine spezialisierte Ausbildung im Bereich Sexualdelikte. Die Mehrheit dieser Beamten widmet ihre Arbeit ausschließlich solchen Fällen.

    Schon vor 2019 begannen Richter in Schleswig-Holstein, aufgezeichnete Vernehmungen in ihre Verfahren einzubeziehen, auch ohne gesetzliche Verpflichtung dazu. Seit 2019 ist dies jedoch gesetzlich vorgeschrieben.

    Bemerkenswert ist die Eröffnung des ersten „Childhood-Hauses“ in Flensburg, das nun den Bemühungen zum Schutz von Opfern und schutzbedürftigen Zeugen in Schleswig-Holstein folgt. Diese Institution, inspiriert vom schwedischen „Barnahus“-Projekt, dient als Maßstab für den Rest des Landes. Ambitionierte Pläne sind in Arbeit, um weitere Zentren in Itzehoe, Lübeck und Kiel einzurichten.

    Vision des Wandels: Hin zu einheitlicher und sicherer Datensouveränität

    Das deutsche Justizsystem, bestehend aus Polizei, Staatsanwaltschaft, Anwälten und Gerichten und funktioniert etwas anders als in anderen Ländern. Ein wesentlicher Faktor ist die Frage, wer die Eigentümerschaft der Fallakten behält. Uwe Keller, ein ehemaliger Beamter aus Schleswig-Holstein, der an der Implementierung dieser Systeme beteiligt war, hält eine Serverlösung – bei der die Daten lokal im Zuständigkeitsbereich der Staatsanwaltschaft gespeichert werden – für besonders passend. Er betont, dass diese Lösung sowohl für Vernehmungen als auch für Metadaten vollständige Datenhoheit gewährleistet.

    In Deutschland gibt es das rechtliche Regelwerk der „Strafprozessordnung“ (StPO), das regelt, wie Polizei, Staatsanwaltschaften, Anwälte und Richter zusammenarbeiten sollen. Ein neu eingeführter Paragraf, §58a StPO, befasst sich speziell mit der Aufzeichnung von Vernehmungen. Die Lösungen von Davidhorn erfüllen diese gesetzlichen Anforderungen vollumfänglich und bieten benutzerfreundliche Werkzeuge, die eine präzise Darstellung der Ereignisse gewährleisten.

    Vor etwa 15 bis 20 Jahren war die Umsetzung dieser Änderungen keine leichte Aufgabe. Doch nun, mit den wertvollen Lektionen aus früheren Bemühungen, beschleunigt sich das Tempo des Wandels. Die Vereinfachung des Datenmanagements wird den Arbeitsablauf sowohl für Institutionen als auch für Opfer einfacher und sicherer machen.

    Davidhorn: Ein wertvoller Verbündeter bei der Revolutionierung der Polizeiarbeit

    Aus der Sicht eines Opfers bemühte sich die Polizei Schleswig-Holstein, bessere Beweise zu sichern und einen überlegenen Prozess zu entwickeln. Technologische Hürden waren natürlich Teil der Gleichung, wurden aber von den beteiligten Parteien hervorragend gemeistert. Gemeinsam mit Davidhorn mussten sie überlegen, welche spezifischen Anforderungen erfüllt werden mussten und wie die besten Werkzeuge eingesetzt werden konnten, um diese Anforderungen zu erfüllen.

    Davidhorn war ein wichtiger Partner in diesem Prozess. Die Zusammenarbeit begann mit nur drei Testsets und hat sich im Laufe der Zeit auf alle Sexualstraftatenteams in Schleswig-Holstein ausgeweitet. Ihre Lösungen tragen dazu bei, dass Opfer sexueller Übergriffe angemessen und mit Sorgfalt behandelt werden.

    Es ist jedoch wichtig zu bedenken, dass selbst die fortschrittlichste Technologie nur eine unterstützende Rolle bei Vernehmungen spielen kann. Der Schlüssel liegt in der Annahme der richtigen Denkweise, Prozesse und Verfahren. Glücklicherweise bietet Davidhorn auch in diesem Bereich die passenden Lösungen. Polizisten sind der erste Ansprechpartner, aber wenn sie nicht wissen, wie sie reagieren sollen, kann kein Fortschritt erzielt werden. Sie müssen wissen, wie sie effektiv und angemessen reagieren können – ein weiterer Bereich, in dem Davidhorns Expertise ins Spiel kommt.

    Die Kombination aus engagierten Beamten, spezialisierten Staatsanwälten und Anwälten, kooperativen Richtern und innovativen technischen Lösungen hat Schleswig-Holstein in Deutschland an die Spitze des Opferschutzes gebracht. Dieser progressive Ansatz hat das Potenzial, in ganz Deutschland adaptiert und weiterentwickelt zu werden, um die Unterstützung für Opfer sexueller Straftaten zu verbessern und das Justizsystem insgesamt transparenter und gerechter zu machen.

    Verfasst von: Marta Hopfer-Gilles

    (Chat GPT wurde bei der Erstellung dieses Blogs verwendet)

    Verwandte Produkte

    • Fixed Vernehmungsrekorder

      Vernehmungsrekorder von Davidhorn: Vielseitiger HD-Recorder für Verdächtige, Zeugenbefragungen und ABE-Aufnahmen….

    • Beweiserfassung: Aufzeichnungsapp

      Beweiserfassung mit Davidhorn: Erfassen Sie Ereignisse, führen Sie Tatortmanagement durch und zeichnen Sie…

    • Tragbarer Vernehmungs-Recorder

      Leichter Vernehmungsrekorder für jede Umgebung, der den strengsten Gesetzen entspricht.

    Juni 13, 2024
  • Prof. Laurence Alison über das Orbit-Modell – ep.13

    Prof. Laurence Alison über das Orbit-Modell – ep.13
    Police Interview Recording

    The Long Game Series

    Episode 23. The 39% Problem: Why Written Interview Records Fail Justice 

    Interview documentation captures only 39% of what’s actually said. Dr. Adrian Gates reveals why written records undermine investigative interviewing and justice and why police interview recording

    In this compelling episode of Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, host Dr. Ivar Fahsing speaks with Dr. Adrian Gates, former Detective Sergeant with An Garda Síochána and current CEO of Insight Interviewing Ltd, about a critical but overlooked problem in criminal investigations: the shocking gap between what happens in police interviews and what gets documented.

    Dr. Gates’ doctoral research at the University of Portsmouth reveals that handwritten and typed interview statements capture only 39% of what suspects actually say during interviews. Analysing 26.5 hours of footage across 15 interviews, he found that 157,000 spoken words were reduced to just 28,000 written words, with 4,481 items omitted across all interviews. 

    This episode traces Dr. Adrian Gates’ evolution from a young detective immersed in “confession culture” to a leading voice for ethical, information-gathering approaches to investigative interviewing. He candidly shares his journey from prioritising confessions to understanding the operationalisation of the presumption of innocence, influenced by his studies with Professor Becky Milne and encounters with international experts. 

    He discusses the implementation of Ireland’s PEACE-inspired interview model (GSIM – Garda Síochána Interview Model), the challenges of changing police culture, and why the physical act of writing during interviews fundamentally undermines both the interview process and the accuracy of evidence. His research demonstrates that scribes interrupt suspects at critical moments, breaking rapport and preventing the free flow of information that ethical interviewing demands. 

    The conversation explores how recording technology – like Davidhorn’s A/V systems – offers the solution to this documentation crisis, enabling accurate transcripts while allowing interviewers to focus on building rapport and gathering comprehensive information rather than controlling the narrative through their pen.

    Key Topics Discussed: 

    • The transition from “confession culture” to information-gathering approaches
    • Implementation of the GSIM (Garda Síochána Interview Model) in Irish policing  
    • Research findings: only 39% accuracy in written interview records  
    • The impact of real-time writing on interview dynamics and suspect cooperation 
    • Why recording technology is essential for justice and the presumption of innocence
    • The cognitive impossibility of accurate manual documentation (30 words/minute writing vs 150-200 words/minute speech) 
    • How scribing interruptions break rapport and prevent information disclosure 
    • The future of interview documentation in Irish criminal justice  

    About the guest

    Dr. Adrian Gates

    Adrian Gates is a former Detective and Sergeant in An Garda Síochána, Ireland’s national police service, where he specialised in serious and complex crimes. He led the development and implementation of investigative interview training and strategic interview policy in Ireland, introducing the Cognitive Interview to criminal investigations in the Republic. A member of the International Investigative Interviewing Research Group (IIIRG) and the Portsmouth University Centre of Forensic Interviewing, Mr. Gates has completed his doctorate at the University of Portsmouth, focusing on the evidential consistency of written records from suspect interviews. He is CEO of Mosney Unlimited Company and Managing Director of Insight Interviewing Ltd, providing scientifically-based, ethical investigative interviewing training and advice to public and private sectors. 

     

    Watch and listen wherever you get your podcasts (YouTube link here)

    Verwandte Produkte

    • Fixed Vernehmungsrekorder

      Vernehmungsrekorder von Davidhorn: Vielseitiger HD-Recorder für Verdächtige, Zeugenbefragungen und ABE-Aufnahmen….

    • Tragbarer Vernehmungs-Recorder

      Leichter Vernehmungsrekorder für jede Umgebung, der den strengsten Gesetzen entspricht.

    • Beweiserfassung: Aufzeichnungsapp

      Beweiserfassung mit Davidhorn: Erfassen Sie Ereignisse, führen Sie Tatortmanagement durch und zeichnen Sie…

    • Software zur Vernehmungsverwaltung: Ark

      Empfangen, überwachen und archivieren Sie Beweismittel während der gesamten Lebensdauer mit einer umfassenden…

    Abschrift

    Guest:  Dr Adrian Gates, former Garda Síochána (Ireland), national lead on investigative interview training

    Host: Dr Ivar Fahsing


    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [00:05]

    Welcome, Adrian Gates, to this episode of Beyond a Reasonable Doubt.

    [00:12]

    This season is all about the implementation of investigative interviewing — and we are going to talk about both the near and the far horizons. Thank you for being our guest today.

    Adrian Gates  [00:24]

    Thank you, Ivar. It is my pleasure to be here. I am a fan of your podcast and I have listened to many very esteemed academics and practitioners. I consider myself very lucky to be here, and I look forward to our conversation.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [00:40]

    And to Adrian, and to our listeners who may not know you as well as I do — could you give a short introduction of who you are, where you come from, and what you currently do?

    Adrian Gates  [00:56]

    Absolutely. I am no longer in the police — which in Ireland is An Garda Síochána, meaning ‘the guardians of the peace’. I joined originally in 1999, went through the Garda Training College in Templemore — which takes about 15 months before you become operational — and was then posted to a busy Dublin city centre station called Pearse Street.

    [00:56]

    We had very little training in interviewing or investigation, so a lot of it was based on what I observed and who I happened to be working with on any given day. Within about three and a half years I was posted to a busy Dublin station in Swords, where I was part of a crime task force driving around the north of Dublin city in response vehicles for two years. After that I moved into a local detective unit, where I spent a number of years investigating everything from ordinary crime to sexual assaults and murder.

    [00:56]

    It was around 2014 that I realised interviewing — suspects and witnesses — was something I was very interested in and quite good at. At that time there was very much what you or Asbjørn Rachlew would describe as a ‘cough culture’, where the whole plan was to get someone to confess. If a suspect was in front of us, we automatically assumed they were guilty — we engaged in confirmation bias and went looking for information that suited our case theory.

    [00:56]

    But as time went on I realised that I was not particularly skilful, and neither were those around me. So I started to look into the academic world and I found a book by Becky Milne and Ray Bull called Investigative Interviewing, and it made a lot of sense. Another book, Conversation Management by Eric Shepherd and Andy Griffiths. Having read both, I decided to go back to study. I had a previous degree in business and management, but I enrolled at the University of Portsmouth with Professor Becky Milne, who has been my mentor ever since.

    [03:52]

    It is funny — I was invited over by Becky to a conference, and I walked into the room, and there you were sitting there. I was this young detective from Ireland with a growing interest in investigative interviewing but really not knowing what I was talking about — I had read a couple of books and looked at a few things online. I think that was my first real introduction to you, Ivar, and also my first proper academic argument.

    [03:52]

    Because what you were saying at the time was very foreign to me. You were saying that everyone has the right to silence, to say what they want or say nothing at all — that it is not up to us to make them talk. I think what you were really pointing to was the operationalisation of the presumption of innocence. My counter-argument was: what about the victims of these crimes? What about their families? I was completely certain I was saying the right things, because in my mind the job of the police was to find the person who committed a crime and to find information to make them confess.

    [03:52]

    When I look back on that meeting — just over ten years ago now — it is quite embarrassing to think that was how I thought. But that is how I had learned it from everyone around me. I had been singled out to interview certain types of interviewee — suspects, witnesses, victims — because I was considered gentle in manner and good with people. And I think even my superiors at the time realised I was actually good at gathering information, though I still had that drive between my teeth. There was always a question waiting for me at the end of an interview: ‘Did you get it?’ — meaning the confession. And we always felt a little like failures if we did not.

    [06:17]

    After completing the master’s, I conducted a study with Becky Milne on the Garda Síochána Interview Model — GSIM — which is the investigative interviewing model used in Ireland. It originated around 2010, with formal rollout beginning after HQ Directive 20 of 2014. It is broadly similar to the PEACE model in the UK, with the same kinds of phases: plan and prepare; engage and explain (called ‘force contact rapport’ in GSIM); account, clarify and challenge; and closure.

    [06:17]

    I was sent on the course just over ten years ago, and I think those running it were a little wary of me because of my connection with Becky Milne. I have to credit my Detective Sergeant at the time, Adrian Murray, as a real mentor — he made sure I got onto the course. And there was a Sergeant called Marianne Cusack who did a huge amount of work to advance the process, because as you know, Ivar, a lot of these things are driven from the bottom — sometimes by just one or two people. It was Geraldine Noon who was really behind developing the model originally. After Geraldine left, Marianne stepped in as Sergeant in charge of investigative interviewing to keep it moving. Then I was brought in as a trainer and eventually became the national lead on investigative interview training in Ireland.

    [06:17]

    I was then moved into the National Bureau of Criminal Investigation — the NBCI — a national detective unit specialising in serious and complex crime across the country. At the same time I was working almost on a hybrid basis, spending about half my time teaching and lecturing at the Garda College on investigative interviewing, and the other half conducting interviews. From a development point of view it was excellent — it gave me a real opportunity to compare what we were doing in the field with what we were doing in training.

    [06:17]

    I was subsequently promoted to Sergeant and took over from Marianne Cusack as Sergeant in charge of the investigative interviewing section at the Garda College. It was there that I realised how much work remained to be done. A lot of that work was informed by my master’s research with Becky. Two things stood out clearly. The first was the lack of ongoing training and supervision. The PEACE model includes an evaluation phase — the GSIM did not, or at best it was implicit. The second was that there was a standalone rapport phase within the GSIM, and I believe — and my findings confirmed — that it caused problems.

    [10:01]

    The rapport building I observed was often perfunctory — interviewers were building rapport for the sake of it, because it was a stage in a model. And then it was almost Jekyll and Hyde: once they reached what they felt was the challenge phase, Mr Hyde appeared. The rapport stopped because they felt they had done the rapport stage and could move on. That was one of the areas we found was really lacking. The other was a lack of understanding of the Cognitive Interview and the Enhanced Cognitive Interview — how to actually conduct them.

    [10:01]

    The advanced interview course at Level 3 was three weeks — two weeks on suspect interviewing, one week on witness interviewing. With Becky, I identified that the training really needed to be rethought. She brought me over to the UK and I observed a number of sessions she ran with police organisations there. When I came back to Ireland I said: we need to change how we do this, because what we are doing is not cognitive interviewing. Even in how we train it, we were using a false scenario — someone reads a script and pretends to be an interviewee — and then you are teaching an interviewer to help a witness become comfortable and access memories that do not exist, because there were no real memories. We changed that, and started using simulated crimes so that trainees were working with real memories of real events.

    [12:12]

    At this point there had still never been an Enhanced Cognitive Interview conducted in Ireland. I remember calling Becky one day and saying: ‘Becky, the legislation supports this. I am going to do one.’ We had a local case — an attempted abduction of a young woman. I explained to my Detective Sergeant what I wanted to do. He gave me the go-ahead. I was building up to the context reinstatement, the interviewee was nicely relaxed — and then the door burst open. Someone walked in holding a cup of coffee and said: ‘Oh, sorry about that!’ and shut the door again. I thought: that is it, it is finished.

    [12:12]

    But we got it back on track. And when I handed the conversation over to the witness, I sat back — and she spoke for 32 minutes uninterrupted. I did not think it was possible. When other people learned what had happened, what was achievable, the amount of information that had come out — it started to spread. I began to gain a little credibility. I was invited to do seminars around the country, going from stations to divisions to districts. I started making quite a name for myself, which was never my intention.

    [13:50]

    Because as you know, detectives and investigators — it is, let us be honest, quite a sought-after position. Everyone wants to be the detective. And because investigative interviewing was relatively new, people believed it was somewhere between psychology and black magic. When we went into police stations to conduct Level 3 interviews with Level 4 interview advisors, there was this aura around us — everyone wanted to know how they could do it, how to get on the course and be part of this new movement. But for me there were always alarm bells. Sometimes I felt the wrong people were coming through.

    [15:01]

    One particular conference comes to mind. I went with a legendary Detective Sergeant called Peter Woods — not long retired, a really excellent interviewer and good man who had been involved in some very high-profile cases. It was a rainy afternoon. The Assistant Commissioner, the Chief Superintendent, the Detective Chief Superintendent who headed the NBCI — all were there to hear various talks on different areas of policing. Then Adrian Gates got up to talk on the Enhanced Cognitive Interview.

    [15:01]

    I always like to start by creating a false memory. I had this chart and I could see them all studying it. I said: ‘I can pretty much guarantee that half of you will recall words you did not even see.’ We went through the whole process and it worked, as it always does. I could see that my chief at the time was, if not impressed, certainly amused. And then at the end, a Detective Superintendent put his hand up and said — and I will never forget this, Ivar — ‘Adrian, are you telling me that we have been doing it wrong all this time?’

    [15:01]

    I had to think. And one thing I have never lacked is the courage to say what needs to be said. I simply said: yes. A number of them nearly fell off their chairs. Some found it very amusing. Some did not find it amusing at all. I thought: that is the end of me. But it was not. I went on to conduct many more Enhanced Cognitive Interviews in the field — real cases. Becky Milne came over and ran a train-the-trainer programme with eight of us, and it took off from there.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [17:48]

    That is a fascinating story. And I have to say it is remarkable to hear — there are points where I feel we have been on exactly the same path. The courage it takes to promote fundamental change in something that is seen as such a basic task.

    [17:48]

    I think one of the questions we said we would explore today is the ethos of investigative interviewing. You have been talking about the first research-based methodology — the Enhanced Cognitive Interview — but what would you say the ethos of investigative interviewing actually is?

    Adrian Gates  [18:42]

    I am happy to answer this — and it should never be a simple answer. Ten years ago it would have been simple for me: I would have said it is about respect, empathy, rapport, and honesty. But that is not really what it is about.

    [18:42]

    For me, the ethos of investigative interviewing has to be — and I am repeating something you have said often, Ivar — operationalising the presumption of innocence. It cannot start from anything more or less than that. Because if you as an investigator are protecting the presumption of innocence, and you genuinely presume that the person in front of you is innocent, everything changes. You do not go in with a fixed mindset. You do not chase information that suits the case theory. That requires a huge mindset shift — talking about it is very cheap.

    [18:42]

    As Sergeant in charge of the investigative interviewing section, I reviewed hundreds of interviews. One of my initiatives was a training passport: interviewers would submit an interview with a suspect and the corresponding written statement. I could see in those interviews — people I had personally trained, whose performance I had watched — the difference between what they did directly after training at the college and what came back from the field. And those interviews coming back from the field were probably their best, the ones they felt most confident about. To say that some had reverted to type is an understatement.

    [18:42]

    That is why the question of what investigative interviewing is comes back to the presumption of innocence. Without that genuine mindset shift, I think a lot of the training is wasted.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [21:30]

    I think you are so right. It reminds me of a few years ago when we were fortunate enough to be invited to Fiji to train. The New Zealand Police had been introducing the PEACE model there over several years, but they said it just was not sticking. I think what had been missed is that this is something much deeper than a stage model. If you just deliver the stage model well, does it really change anything?

    [21:30]

    What we saw in Fiji is that it is a very tribal and intensely religious community — everything was seen through the lens of sin, even the mere suspicion of having done something. So punishment could begin before the interview. Someone being beaten just because they had become a suspect was almost seen as the duty of an elder. When we started to talk about the presumption of innocence and how easy it is to fall into these patterns — and how cultural and historical they are — that was so interesting to observe in that context. Investigative interviewing came about in the first place because of miscarriages of justice. Wrong people convicted. A cultural presumption of guilt. It was brought in to change something fundamental.

    Adrian Gates  [23:36]

    I was involved in one very high-profile interview — quite an emotional experience, because it concerned the shooting and killing of one of our colleagues, whose brother worked with me and was my partner at the time. I ultimately moved on, but I was involved in the investigation and spent a great deal of time with one of the suspects. I had to check myself during those interviews — and I had an outstanding Level 4 interview advisor, Detective Sergeant Adrian Murray, giving me real-time feedback. He was telling me to slow down, helping me manage my performance. This kind of live supervision was not common. I said to him: I am the national lead, I know how to do this. But I was getting caught up.

    [23:36]

    What I can say is this: at the end of that interview process, the person in question shook my hand and left. About four months later I was walking in my hometown with my wife and three children, and the same person came walking down the same path. He looked at me, I looked at him. We recognised each other. And he simply nodded. I think that says a great deal about what it means to approach an interview as someone gathering information — not reaching a verdict. Because by doing that, I was able to maintain a relationship. Not friendship — just humanity. Real rapport does not mean talking about the football. It means meaning it. Meaning that you want to understand.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [26:10]

    That nod says a lot. And I think when we work in this field we become cynical over time. What detectives do every day — accusation — if you transferred that to ordinary life, to family life or friendship, imagine how rarely we actually accuse someone, and what impact that has on a relationship. We do it every day in this work and it becomes bread and butter. I do not think many people truly understand what it means to the person on the other side of that table.

    [27:10]

    You may remember a story I told you — it was the christening day of my middle boy. The party had finished, I was bathing my son, and I got a call from a friend who was supposed to be getting a bus back to Dublin. There was screaming — someone was attacking him. I handed the baby to my wife, jumped in the car, drove three or four minutes, found a gang of people around him, pulled him out and drove away. There was blood running down his face. I called the local station and said we needed to go in and report this. He told me: a man asked him for a cigarette, ran away, and then he noticed his wallet was gone. He chased the man, was screaming at him, and someone came out of a pub and started hitting him.

    [27:10]

    And then my phone rang. It was my friend’s father. He said: ‘Is such and such with you?’ Yes. ‘Oh good — I couldn’t get him on the phone. Will you tell him he left his wallet on the table?’ We stood the police cars down. And I think it is a perfect everyday example of how we form an idea in our heads and then find a way to prove it.

    Adrian Gates  [29:09]

    It is compelling — I use a similar story with my students, which I call the Monster Story. A woman is late for her plane and stops to buy a bag of crisps and a drink. She puts them down at a table near her gate where a man is sitting, and then goes to the toilet. When she comes back she sees the man reach into her bag of crisps and eat one. She demonstratively turns the bag towards herself and starts eating. He turns it back and takes another. She grabs the bag, looks at him, and screams: ‘You bloody monster!’ Then boarding is called. She runs to the gate, hands over her ticket — and finds her own unopened bag of crisps in her handbag. Very similar to your story, but I think it captures something fundamental about how accusation and suspicion arise — and why we have to dare to dig deeper before we conclude anything.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [30:44]

    I could not agree more about the ethos of investigative interviewing. I will also ask you — you have already told us something about your work introducing investigative interviewing in Ireland. Did you meet barriers along the way?

    Adrian Gates  [31:05]

    Yes. Anyone who is introducing or trying to advance something new within a hierarchical institution — and policing is as hierarchical as it gets — will meet the weight of tradition. The same as you always did, you get what you always got. The ECI conference I described was an example of that.

    [31:05]

    And then there was another side to it. Around 2016 to 2018, investigative interviewing was genuinely in vogue in Ireland. Every SIO, every Superintendent, every Detective Inspector wanted trained people on their teams — because the courts were starting to ask for the qualifications of the interviewer. But I do not think many of the more senior officers truly believed in it. They knew they had to go along with it and have certain numbers on paper. When it came to difficult cases — where there was scant evidence and a real hope of a confession — I saw them revert to their trusted disciples. On one hand supporting investigative interviewing, on the other hand putting someone in who would ask tough questions and might get the confession.

    [31:05]

    I have been away from the police for six years, and I do not really think that has changed. I spoke recently with someone who trained around the same time as me — over ten years ago — and they have still not been reviewed since, despite having conducted a very large number of interviews. By prioritising new Level 3 trainees and not investing in the ongoing training and review of existing Level 3 interviewers, we are, I believe, wasting the money and the effort.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [35:07]

    I have to be honest with you about something I have always found remarkable. Am I right that in Ireland, to this day, interviewers still have to write down by hand what is said during a suspect interview?

    Adrian Gates  [35:31]

    Yes — and it is actually the basis of my doctoral research with Becky Milne. A lot of people find it very difficult to comprehend. In Ireland we have had audio-visual recording since 1997. But we are also mandated by the caution to write everything down. The caution states: ‘You are not obliged to say anything unless you wish to do so, but whatever you do say will be taken down in writing and may be given in evidence.’ So we record the interview on video and simultaneously write everything down.

    [35:31]

    I was a reasonably good interviewer. I was able to build relationships, leave my ego at the door, and people would start talking. And then I would realise — the pen cannot keep up with the mouth. In one high-profile murder investigation, the suspect had chosen to say nothing — as was his right. About 30 minutes into the interview he looked at me and said: ‘Adrian, you know why I was there. You all know why I was there.’ And at that precise moment the scribe put a hand up and said: ‘Whoa — can you not see I have to write everything down?’ It was not the first time something like that had happened. I did it myself earlier in my career.

    [35:31]

    The problem with that writing is fundamental. When you so demonstrably take control of someone’s story through your pen, it can easily become your narrative that dominates the room — and the interviewee’s memory. This connects to research by a Swedish researcher called Arne Trankell, who observed police interviews and described how both individuals in the room can lose the grasp of the real story. They become slaves to the task of producing a document. The interviewee wants to help — but you as the interviewer do not know the story. You know what it needs to look like in order to support a prosecution.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [38:25]

    Could you give us a short summary of what your research found?

    Adrian Gates  [38:28]

    The research question was: to what extent do typed or handwritten statements from interviews with suspects actually reflect what was said in the interviews? I collected 15 interviews — equating to 26 and a half hours of footage — and transcribed every single one. That took me a year and a half.

    [38:28]

    At a macro level: the transcripts contained 157,000 words. The written statements contained 28,000 words. In the transcripts there were 2,667 questions asked; in the written statements, 1,244 questions were documented. The average interview transcript ran to 43 pages; the average written statement to 11 pages. The accuracy level was 39% — which gave a figure of 4,481 omitted items across the 15 interviews.

    [38:28]

    When you look at the underlying mechanics: the average writing speed is around 30 words per minute. The average rate of speech is between 150 and 200 words per minute. Even taking the lower figure of 150 and dividing by 30, you are at about 20%. So physically and cognitively, without any interruptions at all, we can capture around 20% of what is being said. A Swedish study from 2018 by March and colleagues found that approximately 24% of spoken words were captured, which is close to that theoretical limit.

    [38:28]

    But it was not just the inaccuracy of the written product. I also examined the interactional architecture of the interviews — the dynamics between interviewer and interviewee — and found that the writing was actively controlling behaviour. It manifested in frequent interruptions specifically designed to stop the person from talking. So the issue is not only what is captured inaccurately. It is also what is never captured at all because of those interruptions. The skill level — the process that should get you to the statement — is far lower than it should be, because interviewers cannot build rapport or ask appropriate questions while managing a pen. And it goes all the way back to the presumption of innocence and the goal of gathering as much reliable information as possible.

    [43:43]

    It is something that is on the radar. I am told that a change to the caution is imminent. There is already legislation — Section 57 of the Criminal Justice Act 2007 — which provides for recordings and transcripts to be used in evidence. So it can actually be done. But again: do what you always did, get what you always got.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [44:04]

    Adrian Gates, thank you for a wonderful conversation. And I urge all our listeners to get hold of that thesis when it is published — it really is essential reading.

    Adrian Gates  [44:14]

    Thank you, Ivar. My pleasure. Thank you very much.


    END OF TRANSCRIPT

    © 2026 Davidhorn. All rights reserved.

    Mehr erfahren

    September 3, 2026
  • Prof. Laurence Alison über das Orbit-Modell – ep.13

    Prof. Laurence Alison über das Orbit-Modell – ep.13

    The Long Game Series

    Episode 23. The 39% Problem: Why Written Interview Records Fail Justice 

    Interview documentation captures only 39% of what’s actually said. Dr. Adrian Gates reveals why written records undermine investigative interviewing and justice. 

    In this compelling episode of Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, host Dr. Ivar Fahsing speaks with Dr. Adrian Gates, former Detective Sergeant with An Garda Síochána and current CEO of Insight Interviewing Ltd, about a critical but overlooked problem in criminal investigations: the shocking gap between what happens in police interviews and what gets documented.

    Dr. Gates’ doctoral research at the University of Portsmouth reveals that handwritten and typed interview statements capture only 39% of what suspects actually say during interviews. Analysing 26.5 hours of footage across 15 interviews, he found that 157,000 spoken words were reduced to just 28,000 written words, with 4,481 items omitted across all interviews. 

    This episode traces Dr. Adrian Gates’ evolution from a young detective immersed in “confession culture” to a leading voice for ethical, information-gathering approaches to investigative interviewing. He candidly shares his journey from prioritising confessions to understanding the operationalisation of the presumption of innocence, influenced by his studies with Professor Becky Milne and encounters with international experts. 

    He discusses the implementation of Ireland’s PEACE-inspired interview model (GSIM – Garda Síochána Interview Model), the challenges of changing police culture, and why the physical act of writing during interviews fundamentally undermines both the interview process and the accuracy of evidence. His research demonstrates that scribes interrupt suspects at critical moments, breaking rapport and preventing the free flow of information that ethical interviewing demands. 

    The conversation explores how recording technology – like Davidhorn’s A/V systems – offers the solution to this documentation crisis, enabling accurate transcripts while allowing interviewers to focus on building rapport and gathering comprehensive information rather than controlling the narrative through their pen.

    Key Topics Discussed: 

    • The transition from “confession culture” to information-gathering approaches
    • Implementation of the GSIM (Garda Síochána Interview Model) in Irish policing  
    • Research findings: only 39% accuracy in written interview records  
    • The impact of real-time writing on interview dynamics and suspect cooperation 
    • Why recording technology is essential for justice and the presumption of innocence
    • The cognitive impossibility of accurate manual documentation (30 words/minute writing vs 150-200 words/minute speech) 
    • How scribing interruptions break rapport and prevent information disclosure 
    • The future of interview documentation in Irish criminal justice  

    About the guest

    Dr. Adrian Gates

    Adrian Gates is a former Detective and Sergeant in An Garda Síochána, Ireland’s national police service, where he specialized in serious and complex crimes. He led the development and implementation of investigative interview training and strategic interview policy in Ireland, introducing the Cognitive Interview to criminal investigations in the Republic. A member of the International Investigative Interviewing Research Group (IIIRG) and the Portsmouth University Centre of Forensic Interviewing, Mr. Gates has completed his doctorate at the University of Portsmouth, focusing on the evidential consistency of written records from suspect interviews. He is CEO of Mosney Unlimited Company and Managing Director of Insight Interviewing Ltd, providing scientifically-based, ethical investigative interviewing training and advice to public and private sectors. 

     

    Watch and listen wherever you get your podcasts (Youtube link here)

    Verwandte Produkte

    • Fixed Vernehmungsrekorder

      Vernehmungsrekorder von Davidhorn: Vielseitiger HD-Recorder für Verdächtige, Zeugenbefragungen und ABE-Aufnahmen….

    • Tragbarer Vernehmungs-Recorder

      Leichter Vernehmungsrekorder für jede Umgebung, der den strengsten Gesetzen entspricht.

    • Beweiserfassung: Aufzeichnungsapp

      Beweiserfassung mit Davidhorn: Erfassen Sie Ereignisse, führen Sie Tatortmanagement durch und zeichnen Sie…

    • Software zur Vernehmungsverwaltung: Ark

      Empfangen, überwachen und archivieren Sie Beweismittel während der gesamten Lebensdauer mit einer umfassenden…

    Abschrift

    Guest:  Dr Adrian Gates, former Garda Síochána (Ireland), national lead on investigative interview training

    Host: Dr Ivar Fahsing


    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [00:05]

    Welcome, Adrian Gates, to this episode of Beyond a Reasonable Doubt.

    [00:12]

    This season is all about the implementation of investigative interviewing — and we are going to talk about both the near and the far horizons. Thank you for being our guest today.

    Adrian Gates  [00:24]

    Thank you, Ivar. It is my pleasure to be here. I am a fan of your podcast and I have listened to many very esteemed academics and practitioners. I consider myself very lucky to be here, and I look forward to our conversation.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [00:40]

    And to Adrian, and to our listeners who may not know you as well as I do — could you give a short introduction of who you are, where you come from, and what you currently do?

    Adrian Gates  [00:56]

    Absolutely. I am no longer in the police — which in Ireland is An Garda Síochána, meaning ‘the guardians of the peace’. I joined originally in 1999, went through the Garda Training College in Templemore — which takes about 15 months before you become operational — and was then posted to a busy Dublin city centre station called Pearse Street.

    [00:56]

    We had very little training in interviewing or investigation, so a lot of it was based on what I observed and who I happened to be working with on any given day. Within about three and a half years I was posted to a busy Dublin station in Swords, where I was part of a crime task force driving around the north of Dublin city in response vehicles for two years. After that I moved into a local detective unit, where I spent a number of years investigating everything from ordinary crime to sexual assaults and murder.

    [00:56]

    It was around 2014 that I realised interviewing — suspects and witnesses — was something I was very interested in and quite good at. At that time there was very much what you or Asbjørn Rachlew would describe as a ‘cough culture’, where the whole plan was to get someone to confess. If a suspect was in front of us, we automatically assumed they were guilty — we engaged in confirmation bias and went looking for information that suited our case theory.

    [00:56]

    But as time went on I realised that I was not particularly skilful, and neither were those around me. So I started to look into the academic world and I found a book by Becky Milne and Ray Bull called Investigative Interviewing, and it made a lot of sense. Another book, Conversation Management by Eric Shepherd and Andy Griffiths. Having read both, I decided to go back to study. I had a previous degree in business and management, but I enrolled at the University of Portsmouth with Professor Becky Milne, who has been my mentor ever since.

    [03:52]

    It is funny — I was invited over by Becky to a conference, and I walked into the room, and there you were sitting there. I was this young detective from Ireland with a growing interest in investigative interviewing but really not knowing what I was talking about — I had read a couple of books and looked at a few things online. I think that was my first real introduction to you, Ivar, and also my first proper academic argument.

    [03:52]

    Because what you were saying at the time was very foreign to me. You were saying that everyone has the right to silence, to say what they want or say nothing at all — that it is not up to us to make them talk. I think what you were really pointing to was the operationalisation of the presumption of innocence. My counter-argument was: what about the victims of these crimes? What about their families? I was completely certain I was saying the right things, because in my mind the job of the police was to find the person who committed a crime and to find information to make them confess.

    [03:52]

    When I look back on that meeting — just over ten years ago now — it is quite embarrassing to think that was how I thought. But that is how I had learned it from everyone around me. I had been singled out to interview certain types of interviewee — suspects, witnesses, victims — because I was considered gentle in manner and good with people. And I think even my superiors at the time realised I was actually good at gathering information, though I still had that drive between my teeth. There was always a question waiting for me at the end of an interview: ‘Did you get it?’ — meaning the confession. And we always felt a little like failures if we did not.

    [06:17]

    After completing the master’s, I conducted a study with Becky Milne on the Garda Síochána Interview Model — GSIM — which is the investigative interviewing model used in Ireland. It originated around 2010, with formal rollout beginning after HQ Directive 20 of 2014. It is broadly similar to the PEACE model in the UK, with the same kinds of phases: plan and prepare; engage and explain (called ‘force contact rapport’ in GSIM); account, clarify and challenge; and closure.

    [06:17]

    I was sent on the course just over ten years ago, and I think those running it were a little wary of me because of my connection with Becky Milne. I have to credit my Detective Sergeant at the time, Adrian Murray, as a real mentor — he made sure I got onto the course. And there was a Sergeant called Marianne Cusack who did a huge amount of work to advance the process, because as you know, Ivar, a lot of these things are driven from the bottom — sometimes by just one or two people. It was Geraldine Noon who was really behind developing the model originally. After Geraldine left, Marianne stepped in as Sergeant in charge of investigative interviewing to keep it moving. Then I was brought in as a trainer and eventually became the national lead on investigative interview training in Ireland.

    [06:17]

    I was then moved into the National Bureau of Criminal Investigation — the NBCI — a national detective unit specialising in serious and complex crime across the country. At the same time I was working almost on a hybrid basis, spending about half my time teaching and lecturing at the Garda College on investigative interviewing, and the other half conducting interviews. From a development point of view it was excellent — it gave me a real opportunity to compare what we were doing in the field with what we were doing in training.

    [06:17]

    I was subsequently promoted to Sergeant and took over from Marianne Cusack as Sergeant in charge of the investigative interviewing section at the Garda College. It was there that I realised how much work remained to be done. A lot of that work was informed by my master’s research with Becky. Two things stood out clearly. The first was the lack of ongoing training and supervision. The PEACE model includes an evaluation phase — the GSIM did not, or at best it was implicit. The second was that there was a standalone rapport phase within the GSIM, and I believe — and my findings confirmed — that it caused problems.

    [10:01]

    The rapport building I observed was often perfunctory — interviewers were building rapport for the sake of it, because it was a stage in a model. And then it was almost Jekyll and Hyde: once they reached what they felt was the challenge phase, Mr Hyde appeared. The rapport stopped because they felt they had done the rapport stage and could move on. That was one of the areas we found was really lacking. The other was a lack of understanding of the Cognitive Interview and the Enhanced Cognitive Interview — how to actually conduct them.

    [10:01]

    The advanced interview course at Level 3 was three weeks — two weeks on suspect interviewing, one week on witness interviewing. With Becky, I identified that the training really needed to be rethought. She brought me over to the UK and I observed a number of sessions she ran with police organisations there. When I came back to Ireland I said: we need to change how we do this, because what we are doing is not cognitive interviewing. Even in how we train it, we were using a false scenario — someone reads a script and pretends to be an interviewee — and then you are teaching an interviewer to help a witness become comfortable and access memories that do not exist, because there were no real memories. We changed that, and started using simulated crimes so that trainees were working with real memories of real events.

    [12:12]

    At this point there had still never been an Enhanced Cognitive Interview conducted in Ireland. I remember calling Becky one day and saying: ‘Becky, the legislation supports this. I am going to do one.’ We had a local case — an attempted abduction of a young woman. I explained to my Detective Sergeant what I wanted to do. He gave me the go-ahead. I was building up to the context reinstatement, the interviewee was nicely relaxed — and then the door burst open. Someone walked in holding a cup of coffee and said: ‘Oh, sorry about that!’ and shut the door again. I thought: that is it, it is finished.

    [12:12]

    But we got it back on track. And when I handed the conversation over to the witness, I sat back — and she spoke for 32 minutes uninterrupted. I did not think it was possible. When other people learned what had happened, what was achievable, the amount of information that had come out — it started to spread. I began to gain a little credibility. I was invited to do seminars around the country, going from stations to divisions to districts. I started making quite a name for myself, which was never my intention.

    [13:50]

    Because as you know, detectives and investigators — it is, let us be honest, quite a sought-after position. Everyone wants to be the detective. And because investigative interviewing was relatively new, people believed it was somewhere between psychology and black magic. When we went into police stations to conduct Level 3 interviews with Level 4 interview advisors, there was this aura around us — everyone wanted to know how they could do it, how to get on the course and be part of this new movement. But for me there were always alarm bells. Sometimes I felt the wrong people were coming through.

    [15:01]

    One particular conference comes to mind. I went with a legendary Detective Sergeant called Peter Woods — not long retired, a really excellent interviewer and good man who had been involved in some very high-profile cases. It was a rainy afternoon. The Assistant Commissioner, the Chief Superintendent, the Detective Chief Superintendent who headed the NBCI — all were there to hear various talks on different areas of policing. Then Adrian Gates got up to talk on the Enhanced Cognitive Interview.

    [15:01]

    I always like to start by creating a false memory. I had this chart and I could see them all studying it. I said: ‘I can pretty much guarantee that half of you will recall words you did not even see.’ We went through the whole process and it worked, as it always does. I could see that my chief at the time was, if not impressed, certainly amused. And then at the end, a Detective Superintendent put his hand up and said — and I will never forget this, Ivar — ‘Adrian, are you telling me that we have been doing it wrong all this time?’

    [15:01]

    I had to think. And one thing I have never lacked is the courage to say what needs to be said. I simply said: yes. A number of them nearly fell off their chairs. Some found it very amusing. Some did not find it amusing at all. I thought: that is the end of me. But it was not. I went on to conduct many more Enhanced Cognitive Interviews in the field — real cases. Becky Milne came over and ran a train-the-trainer programme with eight of us, and it took off from there.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [17:48]

    That is a fascinating story. And I have to say it is remarkable to hear — there are points where I feel we have been on exactly the same path. The courage it takes to promote fundamental change in something that is seen as such a basic task.

    [17:48]

    I think one of the questions we said we would explore today is the ethos of investigative interviewing. You have been talking about the first research-based methodology — the Enhanced Cognitive Interview — but what would you say the ethos of investigative interviewing actually is?

    Adrian Gates  [18:42]

    I am happy to answer this — and it should never be a simple answer. Ten years ago it would have been simple for me: I would have said it is about respect, empathy, rapport, and honesty. But that is not really what it is about.

    [18:42]

    For me, the ethos of investigative interviewing has to be — and I am repeating something you have said often, Ivar — operationalising the presumption of innocence. It cannot start from anything more or less than that. Because if you as an investigator are protecting the presumption of innocence, and you genuinely presume that the person in front of you is innocent, everything changes. You do not go in with a fixed mindset. You do not chase information that suits the case theory. That requires a huge mindset shift — talking about it is very cheap.

    [18:42]

    As Sergeant in charge of the investigative interviewing section, I reviewed hundreds of interviews. One of my initiatives was a training passport: interviewers would submit an interview with a suspect and the corresponding written statement. I could see in those interviews — people I had personally trained, whose performance I had watched — the difference between what they did directly after training at the college and what came back from the field. And those interviews coming back from the field were probably their best, the ones they felt most confident about. To say that some had reverted to type is an understatement.

    [18:42]

    That is why the question of what investigative interviewing is comes back to the presumption of innocence. Without that genuine mindset shift, I think a lot of the training is wasted.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [21:30]

    I think you are so right. It reminds me of a few years ago when we were fortunate enough to be invited to Fiji to train. The New Zealand Police had been introducing the PEACE model there over several years, but they said it just was not sticking. I think what had been missed is that this is something much deeper than a stage model. If you just deliver the stage model well, does it really change anything?

    [21:30]

    What we saw in Fiji is that it is a very tribal and intensely religious community — everything was seen through the lens of sin, even the mere suspicion of having done something. So punishment could begin before the interview. Someone being beaten just because they had become a suspect was almost seen as the duty of an elder. When we started to talk about the presumption of innocence and how easy it is to fall into these patterns — and how cultural and historical they are — that was so interesting to observe in that context. Investigative interviewing came about in the first place because of miscarriages of justice. Wrong people convicted. A cultural presumption of guilt. It was brought in to change something fundamental.

    Adrian Gates  [23:36]

    I was involved in one very high-profile interview — quite an emotional experience, because it concerned the shooting and killing of one of our colleagues, whose brother worked with me and was my partner at the time. I ultimately moved on, but I was involved in the investigation and spent a great deal of time with one of the suspects. I had to check myself during those interviews — and I had an outstanding Level 4 interview advisor, Detective Sergeant Adrian Murray, giving me real-time feedback. He was telling me to slow down, helping me manage my performance. This kind of live supervision was not common. I said to him: I am the national lead, I know how to do this. But I was getting caught up.

    [23:36]

    What I can say is this: at the end of that interview process, the person in question shook my hand and left. About four months later I was walking in my hometown with my wife and three children, and the same person came walking down the same path. He looked at me, I looked at him. We recognised each other. And he simply nodded. I think that says a great deal about what it means to approach an interview as someone gathering information — not reaching a verdict. Because by doing that, I was able to maintain a relationship. Not friendship — just humanity. Real rapport does not mean talking about the football. It means meaning it. Meaning that you want to understand.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [26:10]

    That nod says a lot. And I think when we work in this field we become cynical over time. What detectives do every day — accusation — if you transferred that to ordinary life, to family life or friendship, imagine how rarely we actually accuse someone, and what impact that has on a relationship. We do it every day in this work and it becomes bread and butter. I do not think many people truly understand what it means to the person on the other side of that table.

    [27:10]

    You may remember a story I told you — it was the christening day of my middle boy. The party had finished, I was bathing my son, and I got a call from a friend who was supposed to be getting a bus back to Dublin. There was screaming — someone was attacking him. I handed the baby to my wife, jumped in the car, drove three or four minutes, found a gang of people around him, pulled him out and drove away. There was blood running down his face. I called the local station and said we needed to go in and report this. He told me: a man asked him for a cigarette, ran away, and then he noticed his wallet was gone. He chased the man, was screaming at him, and someone came out of a pub and started hitting him.

    [27:10]

    And then my phone rang. It was my friend’s father. He said: ‘Is such and such with you?’ Yes. ‘Oh good — I couldn’t get him on the phone. Will you tell him he left his wallet on the table?’ We stood the police cars down. And I think it is a perfect everyday example of how we form an idea in our heads and then find a way to prove it.

    Adrian Gates  [29:09]

    It is compelling — I use a similar story with my students, which I call the Monster Story. A woman is late for her plane and stops to buy a bag of crisps and a drink. She puts them down at a table near her gate where a man is sitting, and then goes to the toilet. When she comes back she sees the man reach into her bag of crisps and eat one. She demonstratively turns the bag towards herself and starts eating. He turns it back and takes another. She grabs the bag, looks at him, and screams: ‘You bloody monster!’ Then boarding is called. She runs to the gate, hands over her ticket — and finds her own unopened bag of crisps in her handbag. Very similar to your story, but I think it captures something fundamental about how accusation and suspicion arise — and why we have to dare to dig deeper before we conclude anything.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [30:44]

    I could not agree more about the ethos of investigative interviewing. I will also ask you — you have already told us something about your work introducing investigative interviewing in Ireland. Did you meet barriers along the way?

    Adrian Gates  [31:05]

    Yes. Anyone who is introducing or trying to advance something new within a hierarchical institution — and policing is as hierarchical as it gets — will meet the weight of tradition. The same as you always did, you get what you always got. The ECI conference I described was an example of that.

    [31:05]

    And then there was another side to it. Around 2016 to 2018, investigative interviewing was genuinely in vogue in Ireland. Every SIO, every Superintendent, every Detective Inspector wanted trained people on their teams — because the courts were starting to ask for the qualifications of the interviewer. But I do not think many of the more senior officers truly believed in it. They knew they had to go along with it and have certain numbers on paper. When it came to difficult cases — where there was scant evidence and a real hope of a confession — I saw them revert to their trusted disciples. On one hand supporting investigative interviewing, on the other hand putting someone in who would ask tough questions and might get the confession.

    [31:05]

    I have been away from the police for six years, and I do not really think that has changed. I spoke recently with someone who trained around the same time as me — over ten years ago — and they have still not been reviewed since, despite having conducted a very large number of interviews. By prioritising new Level 3 trainees and not investing in the ongoing training and review of existing Level 3 interviewers, we are, I believe, wasting the money and the effort.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [35:07]

    I have to be honest with you about something I have always found remarkable. Am I right that in Ireland, to this day, interviewers still have to write down by hand what is said during a suspect interview?

    Adrian Gates  [35:31]

    Yes — and it is actually the basis of my doctoral research with Becky Milne. A lot of people find it very difficult to comprehend. In Ireland we have had audio-visual recording since 1997. But we are also mandated by the caution to write everything down. The caution states: ‘You are not obliged to say anything unless you wish to do so, but whatever you do say will be taken down in writing and may be given in evidence.’ So we record the interview on video and simultaneously write everything down.

    [35:31]

    I was a reasonably good interviewer. I was able to build relationships, leave my ego at the door, and people would start talking. And then I would realise — the pen cannot keep up with the mouth. In one high-profile murder investigation, the suspect had chosen to say nothing — as was his right. About 30 minutes into the interview he looked at me and said: ‘Adrian, you know why I was there. You all know why I was there.’ And at that precise moment the scribe put a hand up and said: ‘Whoa — can you not see I have to write everything down?’ It was not the first time something like that had happened. I did it myself earlier in my career.

    [35:31]

    The problem with that writing is fundamental. When you so demonstrably take control of someone’s story through your pen, it can easily become your narrative that dominates the room — and the interviewee’s memory. This connects to research by a Swedish researcher called Arne Trankell, who observed police interviews and described how both individuals in the room can lose the grasp of the real story. They become slaves to the task of producing a document. The interviewee wants to help — but you as the interviewer do not know the story. You know what it needs to look like in order to support a prosecution.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [38:25]

    Could you give us a short summary of what your research found?

    Adrian Gates  [38:28]

    The research question was: to what extent do typed or handwritten statements from interviews with suspects actually reflect what was said in the interviews? I collected 15 interviews — equating to 26 and a half hours of footage — and transcribed every single one. That took me a year and a half.

    [38:28]

    At a macro level: the transcripts contained 157,000 words. The written statements contained 28,000 words. In the transcripts there were 2,667 questions asked; in the written statements, 1,244 questions were documented. The average interview transcript ran to 43 pages; the average written statement to 11 pages. The accuracy level was 39% — which gave a figure of 4,481 omitted items across the 15 interviews.

    [38:28]

    When you look at the underlying mechanics: the average writing speed is around 30 words per minute. The average rate of speech is between 150 and 200 words per minute. Even taking the lower figure of 150 and dividing by 30, you are at about 20%. So physically and cognitively, without any interruptions at all, we can capture around 20% of what is being said. A Swedish study from 2018 by March and colleagues found that approximately 24% of spoken words were captured, which is close to that theoretical limit.

    [38:28]

    But it was not just the inaccuracy of the written product. I also examined the interactional architecture of the interviews — the dynamics between interviewer and interviewee — and found that the writing was actively controlling behaviour. It manifested in frequent interruptions specifically designed to stop the person from talking. So the issue is not only what is captured inaccurately. It is also what is never captured at all because of those interruptions. The skill level — the process that should get you to the statement — is far lower than it should be, because interviewers cannot build rapport or ask appropriate questions while managing a pen. And it goes all the way back to the presumption of innocence and the goal of gathering as much reliable information as possible.

    [43:43]

    It is something that is on the radar. I am told that a change to the caution is imminent. There is already legislation — Section 57 of the Criminal Justice Act 2007 — which provides for recordings and transcripts to be used in evidence. So it can actually be done. But again: do what you always did, get what you always got.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [44:04]

    Adrian Gates, thank you for a wonderful conversation. And I urge all our listeners to get hold of that thesis when it is published — it really is essential reading.

    Adrian Gates  [44:14]

    Thank you, Ivar. My pleasure. Thank you very much.


    END OF TRANSCRIPT

    © 2026 Davidhorn. All rights reserved.

    Mehr erfahren

    August 12, 2026
  • Prof. Laurence Alison über das Orbit-Modell – ep.13

    Prof. Laurence Alison über das Orbit-Modell – ep.13
    Torture Prevention in Europe with Therese Rytter

    The Long Game Series

    Episode 21. Beyond the Interview Room: Fight Against Torture in Europe 

    Human rights lawyer Therese Rytter reveals how the CPT prevents torture across 46 European countries – and why investigative interviewing requires more than methods. 

    In this episode of Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, host Dr. Ivar Fahsing speaks with Therese Maria Rytter, international human rights lawyer and outgoing Vice-President of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT), about the critical intersection of legal safeguards, investigative interviewing, and the prevention of torture across Europe. 

    After nearly 12 years with the CPT and 30 years dedicated to protecting human rights internationally, Therese brings unparalleled insight into what actually prevents torture and ill-treatment in police custody, prisons, and other detention settings across the 46 member states of the Council of Europe. As Director of Prevention and Accountability at DIGNITY – Danish Institute Against Torture, and co-author of the landmark Mendez Principles on Effective Interviewing for Investigations and Information Gathering, she represents the bridge between international human rights standards and practical implementation in criminal justice systems. 

    The conversation reveals the CPT’s unique and powerful mandate: conducting surprise visits to police stations, prisons, and psychiatric hospitals throughout Europe, sometimes arriving at midnight on Friday nights when cells are fullest. Therese describes how expert delegations – including lawyers, forensic doctors, psychiatrists, and former police commissioners – spend two weeks in each country, sitting inside cells to speak with detainees, examining injuries, reviewing CCTV footage, and assessing use-of-force records. This unprecedented access allows the CPT to make concrete, evidence-based recommendations tailored to each country’s specific context. 

    Key Topics Discussed: 

    • The CPT’s unique mandate: surprise visits to detention facilities across 46 European countries 
    • Denmark’s leadership role in the international fight against torture 
    • Methodology: expert delegations conducting two-week assessments 
    • The importance of legal safeguards: access to lawyers, doctors, and judicial oversight 
    • Police culture and problematic incentives: bonuses for case closure rates 
    • Confession extraction as a “shortcut” undermining justice 
    • Police officers’ role: upholding rights, not talking suspects out of them 
    • Decision-making tipping points: how uniformed policing creates investigative bias 
    • CPT standards and good practices across policing, prisons, and psychiatric care 
    • The ImpleMendez project: integrating safeguards with evidence-based methods 
    • Why investigative interviewing cannot be viewed in isolation 
    • Recording technology as crucial safeguard and training catalyst 

    Equipped For Justice – Supporting ethical, human rights-compliant investigations worldwide

    About the guest

    Therese Maria Rytter

    Therese Maria Rytter is an international human rights lawyer with 30 years of experience in promoting and protecting human rights, preventing torture, and advancing justice and accountability for international crimes. She serves as Director of Prevention and Accountability at DIGNITY – Danish Institute Against Torture, a human rights development and health organisation working in 15 countries worldwide. 

    From 2014 to 2025, Rytter served as a member and Vice-President of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT), completing three mandates. She has led numerous delegations conducting monitoring visits to countries across the Council of Europe region, assessing the treatment of persons in police custody, prisons, psychiatric hospitals, and other detention settings with a view to preventing torture and ill-treatment. 

    Rytter was one of the co-authors of the Mendez Principles on Effective Interviewing for Investigations and Information Gathering, establishing international standards for non-coercive, rights-compliant investigative practices. Since 2008, she has served as a national expert to the United Nations Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture (SPT). Her work spans legal frameworks, practical implementation, and accountability mechanisms, making her one of Europe’s most influential voices on torture prevention and humane criminal justice practices. 

    Watch and listen wherever you get your podcasts (Youtube link here)

    Verwandte Produkte

    • Fixed Vernehmungsrekorder

      Vernehmungsrekorder von Davidhorn: Vielseitiger HD-Recorder für Verdächtige, Zeugenbefragungen und ABE-Aufnahmen….

    • Tragbarer Vernehmungs-Recorder

      Leichter Vernehmungsrekorder für jede Umgebung, der den strengsten Gesetzen entspricht.

    • Beweiserfassung: Aufzeichnungsapp

      Beweiserfassung mit Davidhorn: Erfassen Sie Ereignisse, führen Sie Tatortmanagement durch und zeichnen Sie…

    • Software zur Vernehmungsverwaltung: Ark

      Empfangen, überwachen und archivieren Sie Beweismittel während der gesamten Lebensdauer mit einer umfassenden…

    Abschrift

    Guest: Therese Rytter

    Host: Dr Ivar Fahsing


    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [00:00]

    This morning I have the pleasure of inviting you, Therese Rytter, as our guest at this Davidhorn podcast Beyond a Reasonable Doubt. A warm welcome.

    Therese Rytter  [00:10]

    Thank you very much.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [00:10]

    Therese, you and I know each other quite well after years where our paths have crossed, but our listeners might not be familiar with who you are and what you do in your daily work. Could you give us a short introduction?

    Therese Rytter  [00:25]

    Absolutely, I’d be happy to. My name is Therese Rytter. I’m a human rights lawyer by training and I am the Director of Prevention and Accountability at the Danish Institute Against Torture, Dignity, based in Copenhagen. I’ve been working in this field of international human rights for the last 30 years — essentially my entire career. In addition to this, I have also been a member of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture for almost 12 years.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [00:56]

    Fascinating. A Danish institute against torture — that’s an interesting place.

    Therese Rytter  [01:03]

    It is indeed. It’s a human rights development and health organisation that works in some 15 countries worldwide. We work in Denmark, of course, but also in a number of other countries, in order to try to prevent the occurrence of torture and other forms of ill-treatment and to pursue accountability — bringing perpetrators to justice and making sure that victims are also able to receive redress.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [01:34]

    Interesting. As far as I know, Denmark actually holds quite an important position when it comes to torture prevention in the international community, doesn’t it?

    Therese Rytter  [01:42]

    That’s very right. Denmark has for several decades been the lead nation internationally in the fight against torture. Both in the United Nations General Assembly and in the UN Human Rights Council, Denmark tables resolutions that every year increase the legal protection against torture. They also support a number of programmes worldwide which seek to put these legal frameworks into practice and ensure they are carried out in everyday life — whether in policing or prison regimes.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [02:19]

    Fascinating and also reassuring — that’s what you should expect from a well-established liberal democracy like Denmark. But you also mentioned that you hold a position in the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture, the CPT. Is that correct?

    Therese Rytter  [02:36]

    That’s absolutely right, yes.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [02:37]

    Could you explain what exactly that is?

    Therese Rytter  [02:40]

    The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture is an expert body — part of the Council of Europe. The Council of Europe is an international human rights and democracy organisation that includes 46 member states, all the way from Norway in the north to Cyprus in the south, including the UK and extending to Turkey and Azerbaijan. Our role is essentially to help states prevent any kind of practice of torture or other forms of inhuman or degrading treatment.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [03:14]

    And for how long have you been in this position?

    Therese Rytter  [03:19]

    Almost 12 years now. I’m ending my third mandate and cannot be re-elected. I’ve served my time in the CPT.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [03:29]

    Fantastic. Thank you for the work you’ve done there. Twelve years is remarkable.

    Therese Rytter  [03:38]

    No, absolutely. It’s been a pleasure — an extremely important piece of work which I feel very honoured to have been part of. The CPT has a very particular and unique mandate, which no other international body holds. The CPT carries out visits to all 46 member states. We move into police stations, prisons, psychiatric hospitals — anywhere where a person can be deprived of their liberty. We sit inside cells and speak with people in police custody or in prison, to understand what their conditions are and how they are being treated. We also speak with staff and with management, so that we can make a thorough assessment, looking into files, records, and CCTV footage. It’s a very professional methodology of collecting evidence, and then of course, at the end of the visit, speaking with the national government to make recommendations on how to strengthen the protection against torture and inhuman treatment.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [04:47]

    Fascinating. So your committee has a mandate approved by the governments of all Council of Europe member states?

    Therese Rytter  [04:59]

    Yes, that’s right. Every single country has acceded to the relevant European convention and has allowed the CPT to carry out visits into any place of detention within the jurisdiction of the state, and to cooperate with the CPT in good faith. This is a commitment they’ve all made voluntarily.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [05:22]

    I see. And how does it work in practice? If you’re going to conduct an inspection of a country, what would typically be the process?

    Therese Rytter  [05:34]

    We assemble a delegation of independent experts — people with backgrounds as lawyers, medical doctors, perhaps with a specialisation in prison medicine, a psychiatrist, or a former police commissioner. We make sure, depending on what we want to do in the country, that we have the right expertise on board to assess the situation at a professional level. The delegation — say, ten persons — will notify the state, usually three or four weeks in advance, saying we will be visiting and we would like credentials to enter any place. Once we arrive, we receive those credentials from the government. We meet with them, seek to understand recent developments, and they explain what progress has been made and what challenges remain. From there, we conduct fact-finding. For two weeks, we work across the country — moving into police stations and prisons, most of which are not notified in advance. We may notify one or two prisons, but the rest will be surprise visits. For police stations, we can arrive around the clock — very often on a Friday or Saturday night, after there have been incidents in the town. We’ll interview persons who are arrested and detained. Our medical and forensic doctors will examine them, photograph any injuries, and review medical files and use-of-force records. There’s a whole methodology for collecting the information we need to assess how people are being treated. We do this across many police stations and prisons, not only in the capital but in remote areas as well. At the very end of the visit, we meet again with senior government representatives — the Minister of Interior, the head of police, the Minister of Justice, the head of the prison service — and present our preliminary observations, covering both good practices we’ve seen and the concerns we have about continuing patterns of violations, or in some cases, patterns of torture.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [08:20]

    So you can actually speak directly with suspects in custody cells or inmates in prisons?

    Therese Rytter  [08:32]

    Absolutely. We have an unimpeded right to enter these areas, to choose exactly who we want to interview, and to speak with them in private. It will not be those persons the police commissioner directs us to — we choose for ourselves. We always insist that no police officer or prison guard is present, because these conversations must be confidential. Otherwise, the person we are speaking with will not feel able to speak freely.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [09:02]

    May I ask — I have a police officer background from Norway and haven’t been able to access prisons or custody cells except in my own country. Could you give us a sense of what you see across Europe?

    Therese Rytter  [09:20]

    Yes, absolutely. We see the whole spectrum. Some countries have modern custody cells — some even have custody suites, entire modernised areas with good physical conditions: daylight, a bed, necessary facilities. These would also include access to an outdoor yard if the person is held for more than 24 hours, meals served, contact with family. That’s at the very good end of the scale. At the other end, we also see very small, dark cells — sometimes pitch dark — without any daylight, where people are locked up with no food or very little food, limited contact with family, and may be confined for many days with limited access to a toilet. Even within Europe, the range runs from A to Z.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [10:27]

    I see. So at one end you have the pressure of being locked up in isolation, and at the other end, direct physical ill-treatment and violence.

    Therese Rytter  [10:47]

    Absolutely. There’s a whole scale. Torture is at the very high end — the most extreme form of ill-treatment. It is very specifically defined: the infliction of severe pain and suffering, done intentionally, by a law enforcement officer, for a specific purpose — to punish, to extract a confession, to intimidate. In Europe, the torture methods we encounter can include severe beatings, electrical shocks, suspension, or waterboarding. But in police custody, what we more commonly encounter falls under what we label inhuman treatment or degrading treatment. If you are locked in a police cell for three days with very little water and no natural light, that will not constitute torture in itself — but it will still be a violation of the prohibition of inhuman and degrading treatment.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [12:05]

    Exactly. And in combination, the cumulative effect may be the same — particularly if the purpose is to make someone confess to a crime they did or did not commit.

    Therese Rytter  [12:22]

    Yes, it’s always a combination of factors. Ultimately, in Europe, it will be the European Court of Human Rights that decides whether particular treatment constitutes inhuman treatment or torture. The CPT is not a judicial body — we won’t label specific kinds of ill-treatment in those terms. Our role is to prevent these practices from occurring in the first place.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [12:47]

    This takes me back to my own time as a detective at Oslo police headquarters, where I have to admit we were quite unaware of what we were dealing with when we held people in custody for weeks and months. I was interviewing suspects myself, and if they didn’t cooperate, we made clear their custody would be prolonged. I don’t think I personally ever told someone to confess or say what I wanted — but it was quite clear, even without saying it explicitly, what they would probably need to say to lift the isolation. Later it occurred to me: in the police, if you want to handle tear gas, you have to experience it yourself. I remember thinking — if you’re a detective dealing with people in custody and isolation, you should probably spend a weekend in total isolation yourself, to understand what that really does to a person.

    Therese Rytter  [14:24]

    Absolutely. Anyone who plays any role in placing people in solitary confinement — whether a court, a prosecutor, or whoever orders such restrictive measures — ought to understand what it actually means to be placed in solitary confinement. That’s crucial.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [14:47]

    I remember my good friend Asbjørn Rachlew — who, as you know, is now the Norwegian representative on your committee — discussing this around 20 years ago with the Norwegian Director of Public Prosecutions, when we were trying to reform suspect interrogation practices. We found your committee’s reports extremely interesting once we discovered they existed. At that time, there were two things the CPT had specifically addressed regarding Norway: a culture of very long periods of custody and isolation, and a lack of recording of interviews.

    Therese Rytter  [15:36]

    Are you serious? Well — that’s certainly not the case anymore.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [15:42]

    Exactly — but this was the late 1990s. I was a relatively young man and a naive believer in Norway as a liberal democracy. I asked people from the Director of Public Prosecutions’ office what they thought about these concerns, why we weren’t addressing them. But there was a sense of dismissiveness — a feeling that the committee simply had to write something about Norway as well, that it wasn’t really that serious.

    Therese Rytter  [16:22]

    No — I can imagine. Unfortunately, we still see this today. Norway has now introduced recording of interviews, but a large number of countries across Europe are still not recording interviews — with suspects, victims, or witnesses. In that sense, many countries are still where Norway was 20 years ago.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [17:00]

    And speaking of that — I believe Denmark still doesn’t have an obligation to record suspect interviews?

    Therese Rytter  [17:07]

    No, we don’t.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [17:10]

    Which is quite striking, given the position Denmark holds that we mentioned earlier. I won’t press you for your personal view on it, but it’s worth reflecting on the fact that even countries with these kinds of international positions need to examine their own practices. Even highly developed democracies can have practices that fall short.

    Therese Rytter  [17:45]

    This is very true. What we also observe is that some countries progress over time — they develop more refined methods and increasingly comply with human rights standards. But we also see countries that regress. They may have had better practices in the past and then, for various reasons, abandon them. It’s a dynamic situation, and that’s precisely why the CPT cannot simply say: we’ve now visited Norway, Norway is doing well in a number of areas, so they no longer need independent monitoring. Any country can fall back.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [18:31]

    Absolutely. I also wanted to ask — because I know from conversations with Asbjørn Rachlew and with yourself — that your work goes beyond the physical and mental treatment of people in custody, prisons, and mental institutions. You also increasingly focus on interview methods.

    Therese Rytter  [18:59]

    We do. First, of course, the CPT’s original focus in terms of safeguards has been what we call the trinity of rights: anyone who is arrested and detained by the police should have the right to notify their family or another third party; they should have the right to a lawyer; and they should have the right to a doctor, who can verify whether the person may have injuries that perhaps originate from the arrest. Being informed of these rights is fundamentally important — this has been a CPT standard from the very outset. What we’ve also said for more than 25 years is that interviewing methodology is crucial. We have long maintained that the sole purpose of interviewing should be to obtain accurate and reliable information about the matter under investigation — not to obtain a confession from someone who, in the eyes of the officers, may be guilty. The presumption of innocence is central. This is a key principle the CPT has applied since its earliest days.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [20:22]

    When you say that, it takes me back to a very important standard you recommended all the way back in 2002 — the year after we started national interview training in Norway. I can’t tell you how important that standard was to us, Therese. Asbjørn Rachlew and I were quite young officers at the time, trying to reform a relatively conservative organisation — the Norwegian Police and Prosecution Service. Finding that kind of standard from a European body like the CPT was so important to us. It validated the idea — it wasn’t just something we’d picked up from studying in the UK. There were other people, and important institutions, who shared the same conviction.

    Therese Rytter  [21:15]

    Exactly. And of course, the CPT was also heavily inspired by the member states it visited. The United Kingdom was one of the main countries at the time that had introduced the PEACE model, and examining that good practice in the UK was something we also took on board. The principle we’ve emphasised is that one should proceed from the evidence to the suspect, not from the suspect to the evidence. This has been a principle underpinning all our work in police custody.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [21:49]

    It’s really fascinating, and I hope the same inspiration you provided to us many years ago is still reaching places where it’s needed. I know that even people within some of these organisations struggle with how they’re perceived when they raise concerns — whether they’re seen as loyal or as critics of their own country.

    Therese Rytter  [22:21]

    I can imagine. We see this as well. The police also protects itself. That’s something we observe — it’s quite rare, when we discover practices of coercive interrogation or other forms of physical ill-treatment in police custody, to also find effective investigations ending in prosecutions and law enforcement officers actually being brought to justice. In a number of countries in Europe, there is still a long way to go.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [22:51]

    I can say that even in this season of Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, there are officers in some European countries who are very reluctant to accept my invitation — though they are honoured to be asked. They are genuinely afraid to speak openly about what their country needs to do to change.

    Therese Rytter  [23:12]

    Yes, I can very much recognise that.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [23:16]

    So again, I think they should look into the CPT reports and find support there, as we did. I’d like to ask you, Therese — do I understand correctly that when you now conduct an inspection in a country, you also look at whether officers are trained and whether there is a policy on how interviews are conducted?

    Therese Rytter  [23:43]

    Yes, absolutely. We look, of course, at what happens within the place of detention. But if you really want to prevent ill-treatment, you need to look outside it as well. We examine a number of systemic factors. We look at how the police is trained — whether the police academy curriculum includes training on how to interview suspects, victims, or witnesses, and whether that interviewing methodology is consistent with investigative interviewing and modern good practice. We also look at the judiciary — for instance, whether a confession obtained through torture would make it all the way to court, or whether a judge would dismiss such evidence. We review interrogation rules and instructions to see whether they comply with international standards. It’s the whole range of issues — both inside and outside the place of detention — because only through this kind of holistic examination can we propose measures that are genuinely relevant to strengthening protection against ill-treatment.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [24:59]

    As you know, I’ve spent much of my professional life trying to introduce investigative interviewing in the Norwegian police and prosecution service, and also in my position at the Norwegian Centre for Human Rights. I work globally with these ideas. But at some point as a police officer you think — perhaps interviewing is the thing, that if we just get the interview right, everything will follow. Sometimes, though, I think we also have to account for the broader context you’re describing. It’s never just one factor.

    Therese Rytter  [25:51]

    It’s the whole picture, absolutely. And it’s very much about culture — the culture within the police. Is it seen as professional to conduct interviews in an investigative manner, or is coercive interviewing considered acceptable? That’s really where it starts. How does a superior within the police react when someone has forced a confession? But it also extends to the prosecution service — are they willing to accept confessions extracted under torture? Are judges willing to close their eyes? It starts with the police, but it does not stop there. It’s essential to have all justice institutions on board. And ultimately, the political level, because it’s the Minister of Justice or the Minister of the Interior who decides what kind of practice a particular country aspires to.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [26:49]

    Exactly. That brings me to a more delicate question, because you mentioned the presumption of innocence, which is a fundamental right for any suspect. I still see, even among researchers across Europe, an engagement with the question of how to make a suspect talk — methods designed to make people cooperate even when they’ve expressed they don’t wish to. I sometimes feel uncomfortable when I reflect on this: is it really the job of a police officer to make someone talk if they’ve already said they don’t want to give a statement?

    Therese Rytter  [27:27]

    Mm.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [27:33]

    …to give a statement in this case.

    Therese Rytter  [27:37]

    No. The police must respect the presumption of innocence and the right to remain silent. If a criminal suspect does not wish to say anything, there’s not a great deal the police can do — they would have to collect other forms of evidence through other sources, whether documentary or otherwise. Absolutely, one cannot force a suspect to speak, and even less so force a suspect to confess.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [28:03]

    Exactly. But very often the physical dimension of coercion is more readily understood and condemned. When it comes to what you might call ‘sweet talk’ — there’s a well-known piece by Professor Peter van Koppen from the Netherlands on what he terms sweet interrogations, where methods of befriending and subtle manipulation are used. That is…

    Therese Rytter  [28:22]

    Mm.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [28:29]

    …not illegal in itself, but it’s done within a context where the person is in isolation, and they are being manipulated into doing things that are not necessarily in their interest.

    Therese Rytter  [28:38]

    Mm.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [28:44]

    So I think it’s really important that people understand what the job actually is. A police officer, in my view, is there to uphold the law and ensure that the suspect knows their rights and can act on them — not to talk them out of exercising those rights.

    Therese Rytter  [28:59]

    Of course. What you call sweet talk is perhaps at the lower end. That should not happen — manipulation should not happen. But what we are looking at in the CPT is not necessarily that level. We focus on more serious practices: sleep deprivation, interviews lasting many hours with no breaks, insufficient food or water, or — during the interview itself — exposure to threats of torture or threats against the person’s family. These are extremely serious, and they are what we pay closest attention to when we receive allegations of that kind.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [29:46]

    Absolutely. And please excuse me for reflecting on the broader cultural dimension here — there still seems to be a culture in which it is considered in the police’s interest for a suspect to talk. I really question that. Should a police officer have any interest in whether a suspect talks or not? Should a detective have any personal stake in the outcome of a case?

    Therese Rytter  [30:18]

    No. We still see countries where police officers are rewarded for having a high number of solved cases. They may receive better bonuses, better salaries, or even promotions. And for some, extracting a confession is seen as a shortcut to closing a case. This is something the CPT is also very attentive to.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [30:44]

    And that’s why culture matters so much. If you want to make changes, you have to work with culture and with a genuine understanding of what the job actually requires. I remember during my PhD research on what I call tipping points in decision-making — factors that can push you towards tunnel vision about guilt — one interviewee in England said something that stayed with me. He observed that even the experience of being a uniformed police officer, where your job is to control crime and stop it, could itself be a tipping point. He said that if you really want to become an investigator, you’re probably a little bit tainted just by coming from a uniformed background. That was a profound insight into what that does to you — because investigation is definitely not about control. It is, and must be, an objective gathering of relevant information.

    Therese Rytter  [31:53]

    Yes. No, absolutely. I completely agree.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [31:55]

    I’m really impressed by the work you’ve done and by what you’ve devoted most of your professional life to. I’m genuinely grateful for what you and the CPT have meant to our country. It was really important to have those reports when we were trying to reform practices in Norway. And I’m not saying everything is good in Norway now — it isn’t — but those reports were an important contribution.

    Therese Rytter  [32:15]

    I’m very happy to hear that, because this is exactly the main purpose of our work — to help as many states as possible with tailor-made recommendations that speak to the very concrete context we see. And the more reports are made public, the more broadly that influence can spread. There’s also an encouraging international trend: a number of states have now committed to what’s called automatic publication of reports. This means that once we issue a report and send it to the government, they carry out some fact-checking, but within a matter of weeks they make it public. That’s very good practice — it means not only the government and the relevant institutions, the police and the prisons, know what was said, but civil society and the broader public as well. We’re seeing an increasing number of states moving in that direction.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [33:18]

    Absolutely. And speaking with you, Therese, reminds me of something important — I think both of us are involved in a European project called Implemendez, which is a funded initiative to broaden understanding of the importance of legal safeguards and scientifically grounded interview methods across Europe. And yet sometimes there seems to be an over-focus on interview methods alone.

    Therese Rytter  [33:48]

    I agree. Interview methods are key, but it’s not only about the moment of the interview — it’s also about what happened before. What we see in a number of countries is that upon arrest, informal conversations begin immediately. Operational police officers — not investigators — start questioning suspects: where were you, what did you do, what have you committed. These are questions that should not take place without the presence of a lawyer. We see this time and again. So it’s also about looking not just at the official interview with the investigator, but at what happened before and what pressures were placed on the person prior to any formal process. And of course all the safeguards we’ve discussed — the right of access to a lawyer, the right of access to a doctor, the right to be brought before a judge to ensure the detention is lawful — all of these build a protective framework to ensure that the right to respect for personal integrity and dignity is upheld.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [35:01]

    We could go on. I couldn’t agree more. I just want to underline: none of this happens in isolation. That was the point of the story I shared from my earlier days — keeping people in custody for prolonged periods, without fully understanding what that meant. If you combine that context with even an apparently open question, you can probably still get the answer that the person knows you want. All of this has to be seen in balance, and only then can we really move forward.

    Therese Rytter  [35:38]

    No, I agree. I very much agree.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [35:40]

    But I have to say — I really encourage our listeners to visit the CPT website through the Council of Europe, and to look into the national reports, as well as the annual recommendations and broader publications, to see how they can provide inspiration for development in all these areas.

    Therese Rytter  [36:05]

    Exactly. And I would also encourage everyone to explore the CPT’s resources more broadly — we have a substantial collection of standards and good practices covering different areas: police, prison systems, psychiatric hospitals, immigration detention centres. All the areas in which people can be deprived of their liberty. I would encourage anyone to read the country-specific reports, but also to look at the generic standards — because those, at the end of the day, are what every country should aspire to comply with.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [36:46]

    Thank you, Therese, and thank you so much for a wonderful conversation. I’ve learnt a great deal.

    Therese Rytter  [36:50]

    Well, thank you. Thank you very much. It was a pleasure to speak with you, as always — always very inspiring.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [36:56]

    Thanks a lot.


    END OF TRANSCRIPT

    © 2026 Davidhorn. All rights reserved.

    Mehr erfahren

    Juni 26, 2026
  • Prof. Laurence Alison über das Orbit-Modell – ep.13

    Prof. Laurence Alison über das Orbit-Modell – ep.13
    Torture Prevention in Europe with Therese Rytter

    The Long Game Series

    Episode 21. Beyond the Interview Room: Fight Against Torture in Europe 

    Human rights lawyer Therese Rytter reveals how the CPT prevents torture across 46 European countries – and why investigative interviewing requires more than methods. 

    In this episode of Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, host Dr. Ivar Fahsing speaks with Therese Maria Rytter, international human rights lawyer and outgoing Vice-President of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT), about the critical intersection of legal safeguards, investigative interviewing, and the prevention of torture across Europe. 

    After nearly 12 years with the CPT and 30 years dedicated to protecting human rights internationally, Therese brings unparalleled insight into what actually prevents torture and ill-treatment in police custody, prisons, and other detention settings across the 46 member states of the Council of Europe. As Director of Prevention and Accountability at DIGNITY – Danish Institute Against Torture, and co-author of the landmark Mendez Principles on Effective Interviewing for Investigations and Information Gathering, she represents the bridge between international human rights standards and practical implementation in criminal justice systems. 

    The conversation reveals the CPT’s unique and powerful mandate: conducting surprise visits to police stations, prisons, and psychiatric hospitals throughout Europe, sometimes arriving at midnight on Friday nights when cells are fullest. Therese describes how expert delegations – including lawyers, forensic doctors, psychiatrists, and former police commissioners – spend two weeks in each country, sitting inside cells to speak with detainees, examining injuries, reviewing CCTV footage, and assessing use-of-force records. This unprecedented access allows the CPT to make concrete, evidence-based recommendations tailored to each country’s specific context. 

    Key Topics Discussed: 

    • The CPT’s unique mandate: surprise visits to detention facilities across 46 European countries 
    • Denmark’s leadership role in the international fight against torture 
    • Methodology: expert delegations conducting two-week assessments 
    • The importance of legal safeguards: access to lawyers, doctors, and judicial oversight 
    • Police culture and problematic incentives: bonuses for case closure rates 
    • Confession extraction as a “shortcut” undermining justice 
    • Police officers’ role: upholding rights, not talking suspects out of them 
    • Decision-making tipping points: how uniformed policing creates investigative bias 
    • CPT standards and good practices across policing, prisons, and psychiatric care 
    • The ImpleMendez project: integrating safeguards with evidence-based methods 
    • Why investigative interviewing cannot be viewed in isolation 
    • Recording technology as crucial safeguard and training catalyst 

    Equipped For Justice – Supporting ethical, human rights-compliant investigations worldwide

    About the guest

    Therese Maria Rytter

    Therese Maria Rytter is an international human rights lawyer with 30 years of experience in promoting and protecting human rights, preventing torture, and advancing justice and accountability for international crimes. She serves as Director of Prevention and Accountability at DIGNITY – Danish Institute Against Torture, a human rights development and health organisation working in 15 countries worldwide. 

    From 2014 to 2025, Rytter served as a member and Vice-President of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT), completing three mandates. She has led numerous delegations conducting monitoring visits to countries across the Council of Europe region, assessing the treatment of persons in police custody, prisons, psychiatric hospitals, and other detention settings with a view to preventing torture and ill-treatment. 

    Rytter was one of the co-authors of the Mendez Principles on Effective Interviewing for Investigations and Information Gathering, establishing international standards for non-coercive, rights-compliant investigative practices. Since 2008, she has served as a national expert to the United Nations Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture (SPT). Her work spans legal frameworks, practical implementation, and accountability mechanisms, making her one of Europe’s most influential voices on torture prevention and humane criminal justice practices. 

    Watch and listen wherever you get your podcasts (Youtube link here)

    Verwandte Produkte

    • Fixed Vernehmungsrekorder

      Vernehmungsrekorder von Davidhorn: Vielseitiger HD-Recorder für Verdächtige, Zeugenbefragungen und ABE-Aufnahmen….

    • Tragbarer Vernehmungs-Recorder

      Leichter Vernehmungsrekorder für jede Umgebung, der den strengsten Gesetzen entspricht.

    • Beweiserfassung: Aufzeichnungsapp

      Beweiserfassung mit Davidhorn: Erfassen Sie Ereignisse, führen Sie Tatortmanagement durch und zeichnen Sie…

    • Software zur Vernehmungsverwaltung: Ark

      Empfangen, überwachen und archivieren Sie Beweismittel während der gesamten Lebensdauer mit einer umfassenden…

    Abschrift

    Guest: Therese Rytter

    Host: Dr Ivar Fahsing


    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [00:00]

    This morning I have the pleasure of inviting you, Therese Rytter, as our guest at this Davidhorn podcast Beyond a Reasonable Doubt. A warm welcome.

    Therese Rytter  [00:10]

    Thank you very much.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [00:10]

    Therese, you and I know each other quite well after years where our paths have crossed, but our listeners might not be familiar with who you are and what you do in your daily work. Could you give us a short introduction?

    Therese Rytter  [00:25]

    Absolutely, I’d be happy to. My name is Therese Rytter. I’m a human rights lawyer by training and I am the Director of Prevention and Accountability at the Danish Institute Against Torture, Dignity, based in Copenhagen. I’ve been working in this field of international human rights for the last 30 years — essentially my entire career. In addition to this, I have also been a member of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture for almost 12 years.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [00:56]

    Fascinating. A Danish institute against torture — that’s an interesting place.

    Therese Rytter  [01:03]

    It is indeed. It’s a human rights development and health organisation that works in some 15 countries worldwide. We work in Denmark, of course, but also in a number of other countries, in order to try to prevent the occurrence of torture and other forms of ill-treatment and to pursue accountability — bringing perpetrators to justice and making sure that victims are also able to receive redress.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [01:34]

    Interesting. As far as I know, Denmark actually holds quite an important position when it comes to torture prevention in the international community, doesn’t it?

    Therese Rytter  [01:42]

    That’s very right. Denmark has for several decades been the lead nation internationally in the fight against torture. Both in the United Nations General Assembly and in the UN Human Rights Council, Denmark tables resolutions that every year increase the legal protection against torture. They also support a number of programmes worldwide which seek to put these legal frameworks into practice and ensure they are carried out in everyday life — whether in policing or prison regimes.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [02:19]

    Fascinating and also reassuring — that’s what you should expect from a well-established liberal democracy like Denmark. But you also mentioned that you hold a position in the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture, the CPT. Is that correct?

    Therese Rytter  [02:36]

    That’s absolutely right, yes.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [02:37]

    Could you explain what exactly that is?

    Therese Rytter  [02:40]

    The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture is an expert body — part of the Council of Europe. The Council of Europe is an international human rights and democracy organisation that includes 46 member states, all the way from Norway in the north to Cyprus in the south, including the UK and extending to Turkey and Azerbaijan. Our role is essentially to help states prevent any kind of practice of torture or other forms of inhuman or degrading treatment.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [03:14]

    And for how long have you been in this position?

    Therese Rytter  [03:19]

    Almost 12 years now. I’m ending my third mandate and cannot be re-elected. I’ve served my time in the CPT.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [03:29]

    Fantastic. Thank you for the work you’ve done there. Twelve years is remarkable.

    Therese Rytter  [03:38]

    No, absolutely. It’s been a pleasure — an extremely important piece of work which I feel very honoured to have been part of. The CPT has a very particular and unique mandate, which no other international body holds. The CPT carries out visits to all 46 member states. We move into police stations, prisons, psychiatric hospitals — anywhere where a person can be deprived of their liberty. We sit inside cells and speak with people in police custody or in prison, to understand what their conditions are and how they are being treated. We also speak with staff and with management, so that we can make a thorough assessment, looking into files, records, and CCTV footage. It’s a very professional methodology of collecting evidence, and then of course, at the end of the visit, speaking with the national government to make recommendations on how to strengthen the protection against torture and inhuman treatment.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [04:47]

    Fascinating. So your committee has a mandate approved by the governments of all Council of Europe member states?

    Therese Rytter  [04:59]

    Yes, that’s right. Every single country has acceded to the relevant European convention and has allowed the CPT to carry out visits into any place of detention within the jurisdiction of the state, and to cooperate with the CPT in good faith. This is a commitment they’ve all made voluntarily.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [05:22]

    I see. And how does it work in practice? If you’re going to conduct an inspection of a country, what would typically be the process?

    Therese Rytter  [05:34]

    We assemble a delegation of independent experts — people with backgrounds as lawyers, medical doctors, perhaps with a specialisation in prison medicine, a psychiatrist, or a former police commissioner. We make sure, depending on what we want to do in the country, that we have the right expertise on board to assess the situation at a professional level. The delegation — say, ten persons — will notify the state, usually three or four weeks in advance, saying we will be visiting and we would like credentials to enter any place. Once we arrive, we receive those credentials from the government. We meet with them, seek to understand recent developments, and they explain what progress has been made and what challenges remain. From there, we conduct fact-finding. For two weeks, we work across the country — moving into police stations and prisons, most of which are not notified in advance. We may notify one or two prisons, but the rest will be surprise visits. For police stations, we can arrive around the clock — very often on a Friday or Saturday night, after there have been incidents in the town. We’ll interview persons who are arrested and detained. Our medical and forensic doctors will examine them, photograph any injuries, and review medical files and use-of-force records. There’s a whole methodology for collecting the information we need to assess how people are being treated. We do this across many police stations and prisons, not only in the capital but in remote areas as well. At the very end of the visit, we meet again with senior government representatives — the Minister of Interior, the head of police, the Minister of Justice, the head of the prison service — and present our preliminary observations, covering both good practices we’ve seen and the concerns we have about continuing patterns of violations, or in some cases, patterns of torture.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [08:20]

    So you can actually speak directly with suspects in custody cells or inmates in prisons?

    Therese Rytter  [08:32]

    Absolutely. We have an unimpeded right to enter these areas, to choose exactly who we want to interview, and to speak with them in private. It will not be those persons the police commissioner directs us to — we choose for ourselves. We always insist that no police officer or prison guard is present, because these conversations must be confidential. Otherwise, the person we are speaking with will not feel able to speak freely.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [09:02]

    May I ask — I have a police officer background from Norway and haven’t been able to access prisons or custody cells except in my own country. Could you give us a sense of what you see across Europe?

    Therese Rytter  [09:20]

    Yes, absolutely. We see the whole spectrum. Some countries have modern custody cells — some even have custody suites, entire modernised areas with good physical conditions: daylight, a bed, necessary facilities. These would also include access to an outdoor yard if the person is held for more than 24 hours, meals served, contact with family. That’s at the very good end of the scale. At the other end, we also see very small, dark cells — sometimes pitch dark — without any daylight, where people are locked up with no food or very little food, limited contact with family, and may be confined for many days with limited access to a toilet. Even within Europe, the range runs from A to Z.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [10:27]

    I see. So at one end you have the pressure of being locked up in isolation, and at the other end, direct physical ill-treatment and violence.

    Therese Rytter  [10:47]

    Absolutely. There’s a whole scale. Torture is at the very high end — the most extreme form of ill-treatment. It is very specifically defined: the infliction of severe pain and suffering, done intentionally, by a law enforcement officer, for a specific purpose — to punish, to extract a confession, to intimidate. In Europe, the torture methods we encounter can include severe beatings, electrical shocks, suspension, or waterboarding. But in police custody, what we more commonly encounter falls under what we label inhuman treatment or degrading treatment. If you are locked in a police cell for three days with very little water and no natural light, that will not constitute torture in itself — but it will still be a violation of the prohibition of inhuman and degrading treatment.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [12:05]

    Exactly. And in combination, the cumulative effect may be the same — particularly if the purpose is to make someone confess to a crime they did or did not commit.

    Therese Rytter  [12:22]

    Yes, it’s always a combination of factors. Ultimately, in Europe, it will be the European Court of Human Rights that decides whether particular treatment constitutes inhuman treatment or torture. The CPT is not a judicial body — we won’t label specific kinds of ill-treatment in those terms. Our role is to prevent these practices from occurring in the first place.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [12:47]

    This takes me back to my own time as a detective at Oslo police headquarters, where I have to admit we were quite unaware of what we were dealing with when we held people in custody for weeks and months. I was interviewing suspects myself, and if they didn’t cooperate, we made clear their custody would be prolonged. I don’t think I personally ever told someone to confess or say what I wanted — but it was quite clear, even without saying it explicitly, what they would probably need to say to lift the isolation. Later it occurred to me: in the police, if you want to handle tear gas, you have to experience it yourself. I remember thinking — if you’re a detective dealing with people in custody and isolation, you should probably spend a weekend in total isolation yourself, to understand what that really does to a person.

    Therese Rytter  [14:24]

    Absolutely. Anyone who plays any role in placing people in solitary confinement — whether a court, a prosecutor, or whoever orders such restrictive measures — ought to understand what it actually means to be placed in solitary confinement. That’s crucial.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [14:47]

    I remember my good friend Asbjørn Rachlew — who, as you know, is now the Norwegian representative on your committee — discussing this around 20 years ago with the Norwegian Director of Public Prosecutions, when we were trying to reform suspect interrogation practices. We found your committee’s reports extremely interesting once we discovered they existed. At that time, there were two things the CPT had specifically addressed regarding Norway: a culture of very long periods of custody and isolation, and a lack of recording of interviews.

    Therese Rytter  [15:36]

    Are you serious? Well — that’s certainly not the case anymore.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [15:42]

    Exactly — but this was the late 1990s. I was a relatively young man and a naive believer in Norway as a liberal democracy. I asked people from the Director of Public Prosecutions’ office what they thought about these concerns, why we weren’t addressing them. But there was a sense of dismissiveness — a feeling that the committee simply had to write something about Norway as well, that it wasn’t really that serious.

    Therese Rytter  [16:22]

    No — I can imagine. Unfortunately, we still see this today. Norway has now introduced recording of interviews, but a large number of countries across Europe are still not recording interviews — with suspects, victims, or witnesses. In that sense, many countries are still where Norway was 20 years ago.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [17:00]

    And speaking of that — I believe Denmark still doesn’t have an obligation to record suspect interviews?

    Therese Rytter  [17:07]

    No, we don’t.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [17:10]

    Which is quite striking, given the position Denmark holds that we mentioned earlier. I won’t press you for your personal view on it, but it’s worth reflecting on the fact that even countries with these kinds of international positions need to examine their own practices. Even highly developed democracies can have practices that fall short.

    Therese Rytter  [17:45]

    This is very true. What we also observe is that some countries progress over time — they develop more refined methods and increasingly comply with human rights standards. But we also see countries that regress. They may have had better practices in the past and then, for various reasons, abandon them. It’s a dynamic situation, and that’s precisely why the CPT cannot simply say: we’ve now visited Norway, Norway is doing well in a number of areas, so they no longer need independent monitoring. Any country can fall back.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [18:31]

    Absolutely. I also wanted to ask — because I know from conversations with Asbjørn Rachlew and with yourself — that your work goes beyond the physical and mental treatment of people in custody, prisons, and mental institutions. You also increasingly focus on interview methods.

    Therese Rytter  [18:59]

    We do. First, of course, the CPT’s original focus in terms of safeguards has been what we call the trinity of rights: anyone who is arrested and detained by the police should have the right to notify their family or another third party; they should have the right to a lawyer; and they should have the right to a doctor, who can verify whether the person may have injuries that perhaps originate from the arrest. Being informed of these rights is fundamentally important — this has been a CPT standard from the very outset. What we’ve also said for more than 25 years is that interviewing methodology is crucial. We have long maintained that the sole purpose of interviewing should be to obtain accurate and reliable information about the matter under investigation — not to obtain a confession from someone who, in the eyes of the officers, may be guilty. The presumption of innocence is central. This is a key principle the CPT has applied since its earliest days.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [20:22]

    When you say that, it takes me back to a very important standard you recommended all the way back in 2002 — the year after we started national interview training in Norway. I can’t tell you how important that standard was to us, Therese. Asbjørn Rachlew and I were quite young officers at the time, trying to reform a relatively conservative organisation — the Norwegian Police and Prosecution Service. Finding that kind of standard from a European body like the CPT was so important to us. It validated the idea — it wasn’t just something we’d picked up from studying in the UK. There were other people, and important institutions, who shared the same conviction.

    Therese Rytter  [21:15]

    Exactly. And of course, the CPT was also heavily inspired by the member states it visited. The United Kingdom was one of the main countries at the time that had introduced the PEACE model, and examining that good practice in the UK was something we also took on board. The principle we’ve emphasised is that one should proceed from the evidence to the suspect, not from the suspect to the evidence. This has been a principle underpinning all our work in police custody.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [21:49]

    It’s really fascinating, and I hope the same inspiration you provided to us many years ago is still reaching places where it’s needed. I know that even people within some of these organisations struggle with how they’re perceived when they raise concerns — whether they’re seen as loyal or as critics of their own country.

    Therese Rytter  [22:21]

    I can imagine. We see this as well. The police also protects itself. That’s something we observe — it’s quite rare, when we discover practices of coercive interrogation or other forms of physical ill-treatment in police custody, to also find effective investigations ending in prosecutions and law enforcement officers actually being brought to justice. In a number of countries in Europe, there is still a long way to go.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [22:51]

    I can say that even in this season of Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, there are officers in some European countries who are very reluctant to accept my invitation — though they are honoured to be asked. They are genuinely afraid to speak openly about what their country needs to do to change.

    Therese Rytter  [23:12]

    Yes, I can very much recognise that.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [23:16]

    So again, I think they should look into the CPT reports and find support there, as we did. I’d like to ask you, Therese — do I understand correctly that when you now conduct an inspection in a country, you also look at whether officers are trained and whether there is a policy on how interviews are conducted?

    Therese Rytter  [23:43]

    Yes, absolutely. We look, of course, at what happens within the place of detention. But if you really want to prevent ill-treatment, you need to look outside it as well. We examine a number of systemic factors. We look at how the police is trained — whether the police academy curriculum includes training on how to interview suspects, victims, or witnesses, and whether that interviewing methodology is consistent with investigative interviewing and modern good practice. We also look at the judiciary — for instance, whether a confession obtained through torture would make it all the way to court, or whether a judge would dismiss such evidence. We review interrogation rules and instructions to see whether they comply with international standards. It’s the whole range of issues — both inside and outside the place of detention — because only through this kind of holistic examination can we propose measures that are genuinely relevant to strengthening protection against ill-treatment.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [24:59]

    As you know, I’ve spent much of my professional life trying to introduce investigative interviewing in the Norwegian police and prosecution service, and also in my position at the Norwegian Centre for Human Rights. I work globally with these ideas. But at some point as a police officer you think — perhaps interviewing is the thing, that if we just get the interview right, everything will follow. Sometimes, though, I think we also have to account for the broader context you’re describing. It’s never just one factor.

    Therese Rytter  [25:51]

    It’s the whole picture, absolutely. And it’s very much about culture — the culture within the police. Is it seen as professional to conduct interviews in an investigative manner, or is coercive interviewing considered acceptable? That’s really where it starts. How does a superior within the police react when someone has forced a confession? But it also extends to the prosecution service — are they willing to accept confessions extracted under torture? Are judges willing to close their eyes? It starts with the police, but it does not stop there. It’s essential to have all justice institutions on board. And ultimately, the political level, because it’s the Minister of Justice or the Minister of the Interior who decides what kind of practice a particular country aspires to.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [26:49]

    Exactly. That brings me to a more delicate question, because you mentioned the presumption of innocence, which is a fundamental right for any suspect. I still see, even among researchers across Europe, an engagement with the question of how to make a suspect talk — methods designed to make people cooperate even when they’ve expressed they don’t wish to. I sometimes feel uncomfortable when I reflect on this: is it really the job of a police officer to make someone talk if they’ve already said they don’t want to give a statement?

    Therese Rytter  [27:27]

    Mm.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [27:33]

    …to give a statement in this case.

    Therese Rytter  [27:37]

    No. The police must respect the presumption of innocence and the right to remain silent. If a criminal suspect does not wish to say anything, there’s not a great deal the police can do — they would have to collect other forms of evidence through other sources, whether documentary or otherwise. Absolutely, one cannot force a suspect to speak, and even less so force a suspect to confess.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [28:03]

    Exactly. But very often the physical dimension of coercion is more readily understood and condemned. When it comes to what you might call ‘sweet talk’ — there’s a well-known piece by Professor Peter van Koppen from the Netherlands on what he terms sweet interrogations, where methods of befriending and subtle manipulation are used. That is…

    Therese Rytter  [28:22]

    Mm.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [28:29]

    …not illegal in itself, but it’s done within a context where the person is in isolation, and they are being manipulated into doing things that are not necessarily in their interest.

    Therese Rytter  [28:38]

    Mm.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [28:44]

    So I think it’s really important that people understand what the job actually is. A police officer, in my view, is there to uphold the law and ensure that the suspect knows their rights and can act on them — not to talk them out of exercising those rights.

    Therese Rytter  [28:59]

    Of course. What you call sweet talk is perhaps at the lower end. That should not happen — manipulation should not happen. But what we are looking at in the CPT is not necessarily that level. We focus on more serious practices: sleep deprivation, interviews lasting many hours with no breaks, insufficient food or water, or — during the interview itself — exposure to threats of torture or threats against the person’s family. These are extremely serious, and they are what we pay closest attention to when we receive allegations of that kind.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [29:46]

    Absolutely. And please excuse me for reflecting on the broader cultural dimension here — there still seems to be a culture in which it is considered in the police’s interest for a suspect to talk. I really question that. Should a police officer have any interest in whether a suspect talks or not? Should a detective have any personal stake in the outcome of a case?

    Therese Rytter  [30:18]

    No. We still see countries where police officers are rewarded for having a high number of solved cases. They may receive better bonuses, better salaries, or even promotions. And for some, extracting a confession is seen as a shortcut to closing a case. This is something the CPT is also very attentive to.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [30:44]

    And that’s why culture matters so much. If you want to make changes, you have to work with culture and with a genuine understanding of what the job actually requires. I remember during my PhD research on what I call tipping points in decision-making — factors that can push you towards tunnel vision about guilt — one interviewee in England said something that stayed with me. He observed that even the experience of being a uniformed police officer, where your job is to control crime and stop it, could itself be a tipping point. He said that if you really want to become an investigator, you’re probably a little bit tainted just by coming from a uniformed background. That was a profound insight into what that does to you — because investigation is definitely not about control. It is, and must be, an objective gathering of relevant information.

    Therese Rytter  [31:53]

    Yes. No, absolutely. I completely agree.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [31:55]

    I’m really impressed by the work you’ve done and by what you’ve devoted most of your professional life to. I’m genuinely grateful for what you and the CPT have meant to our country. It was really important to have those reports when we were trying to reform practices in Norway. And I’m not saying everything is good in Norway now — it isn’t — but those reports were an important contribution.

    Therese Rytter  [32:15]

    I’m very happy to hear that, because this is exactly the main purpose of our work — to help as many states as possible with tailor-made recommendations that speak to the very concrete context we see. And the more reports are made public, the more broadly that influence can spread. There’s also an encouraging international trend: a number of states have now committed to what’s called automatic publication of reports. This means that once we issue a report and send it to the government, they carry out some fact-checking, but within a matter of weeks they make it public. That’s very good practice — it means not only the government and the relevant institutions, the police and the prisons, know what was said, but civil society and the broader public as well. We’re seeing an increasing number of states moving in that direction.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [33:18]

    Absolutely. And speaking with you, Therese, reminds me of something important — I think both of us are involved in a European project called Implemendez, which is a funded initiative to broaden understanding of the importance of legal safeguards and scientifically grounded interview methods across Europe. And yet sometimes there seems to be an over-focus on interview methods alone.

    Therese Rytter  [33:48]

    I agree. Interview methods are key, but it’s not only about the moment of the interview — it’s also about what happened before. What we see in a number of countries is that upon arrest, informal conversations begin immediately. Operational police officers — not investigators — start questioning suspects: where were you, what did you do, what have you committed. These are questions that should not take place without the presence of a lawyer. We see this time and again. So it’s also about looking not just at the official interview with the investigator, but at what happened before and what pressures were placed on the person prior to any formal process. And of course all the safeguards we’ve discussed — the right of access to a lawyer, the right of access to a doctor, the right to be brought before a judge to ensure the detention is lawful — all of these build a protective framework to ensure that the right to respect for personal integrity and dignity is upheld.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [35:01]

    We could go on. I couldn’t agree more. I just want to underline: none of this happens in isolation. That was the point of the story I shared from my earlier days — keeping people in custody for prolonged periods, without fully understanding what that meant. If you combine that context with even an apparently open question, you can probably still get the answer that the person knows you want. All of this has to be seen in balance, and only then can we really move forward.

    Therese Rytter  [35:38]

    No, I agree. I very much agree.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [35:40]

    But I have to say — I really encourage our listeners to visit the CPT website through the Council of Europe, and to look into the national reports, as well as the annual recommendations and broader publications, to see how they can provide inspiration for development in all these areas.

    Therese Rytter  [36:05]

    Exactly. And I would also encourage everyone to explore the CPT’s resources more broadly — we have a substantial collection of standards and good practices covering different areas: police, prison systems, psychiatric hospitals, immigration detention centres. All the areas in which people can be deprived of their liberty. I would encourage anyone to read the country-specific reports, but also to look at the generic standards — because those, at the end of the day, are what every country should aspire to comply with.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [36:46]

    Thank you, Therese, and thank you so much for a wonderful conversation. I’ve learnt a great deal.

    Therese Rytter  [36:50]

    Well, thank you. Thank you very much. It was a pleasure to speak with you, as always — always very inspiring.

    Dr. Ivar Fahsing  [36:56]

    Thanks a lot.


    END OF TRANSCRIPT

    © 2026 Davidhorn. All rights reserved.

    Mehr erfahren

    Juni 4, 2026
Vorherige Seite
1 2 3 4 … 8
Nächste Seite
Davidhorn

Vereinigtes Königreich: +44 (0)1582 490300

Andere Regionen: +47 370 76 460

Vertrieb und Technik:
sales@davidhorn.com

Support:
support@davidhorn.com

  • wpml-ls-flag
    • wpml-ls-flag
    • wpml-ls-flag
    • wpml-ls-flag
    • wpml-ls-flag
    • wpml-ls-flag

Andere Seiten

  • Kontakt
  • Unterstützung
Eine Kiwa-zertifizierte (ISO 19001, ISO 27001) Plakette. Ausgestellt von der norwegischen Akkreditierungsstelle MSYS 004.

Erhalten Sie die neuesten Nachrichten

Dieses Feld dient zur Validierung und sollte nicht verändert werden.
Name(erforderlich)
Newsletter consent(erforderlich)
Read our Privacy Policy.

Melden Sie sich für unseren Newsletter an und erhalten Sie als Erster tolle Angebote und aktuelle Neuigkeiten!


  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Datenschutzbestimmungen

Begriffe

Cookies

©Davidhorn. Code und Design Aptum